House names three constitutional court judges
House names three constitutional court judges
Kurniawan Hari, Muninggar Sri Saraswati, The Jakarta Post,
Jakarta
The selection process of Constitutional Court judges came closer
to completion after the House of Representatives announced its
three preferences.
The three were constitutional law expert Jimly Asshiddiqie,
former House legislator Achmad Rustandi and People's Consultative
Assembly legislator I Dewa Gede Palguna. They beat the other 10
candidates who underwent fit and proper tests on Wednesday and
Thursday.
A plenary House session will be held on Friday to endorse the
three nominees.
The Supreme Court had earlier appointed Laica Marzuki,
Sudarsono, and Muarar Siahaan judges for the new court and the
government was expected to announce its three nominees on Friday.
Based on the amended Constitution, the new court will consist
of nine judges with the House, the President, and the Supreme
Court appointing three each.
The Constitution sets an Aug. 17, 2003 deadline for the
establishment of the Constitutional Court.
Minister of Justice and Human Rights Yusril Ihza Mahendra
disclosed on Thursday the government had received 18 names
nominated as constitutional court judges.
The 18 names included right activists Todung Mulya Lubis,
Benny K. Harman, legislators Harun Kamil, JE Sahetapy, and
lecturers I Dewa Gede Atmadja and Jimly Asshiddiqie.
Harun Kamil and Gede Atmadja had joined in the selection
process in the House and were ranked fifth and tenth
respectively.
Yusril said his team would present six names to the President
who will later pick three out of the six on Friday.
According to him, the President will install the nine judges
on Saturday, which will mark the establishment of the court.
Speaking to the press after finishing the selection on
Thursday, House Commission II chairman Agustin Teras Narang said
that the commission had selected Jimly Asshiddiqie, Achmad
Rustandi, and Palguna as the judges.
As with the selection process used by the National Commission
on Human Rights (Komnas HAM), the House's law commission used a
scoring system for the selection.
Under the scoring system, each legislator is allowed to list
three candidates as their preference.
Of the 49 legislators who voted on Friday Jimly got 37 votes,
Rustandi 26, and Palguna 22.
Jimly was nominated by the Golkar faction while Rustandi and
Palguna were nominated by the United Development Party (PPP)
faction and the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI
Perjuangan) respectively.
Zein Badjeber who chaired a team deliberating the
constitutional court bill hailed the result of the selection.
"All candidates are good, we have selected excellent ones,"
Zein said.
Asked whether Achmad Rustandi -- a former legislator from
military/police faction -- had experience in constitutional
matters, Zein said the requirement was not mandatory.
He said that the judges selected by Supreme Court Chief
Justice Bagir Manan also had no experience in constitutional
matters.
The House was scheduled to examine 14 candidates, but two of
them, Djuhad Mahja and Haryono nominated respectively by PPP and
PDI Perjuangan, withdrew.
Candidates vote ranking
----------------------------------------
No. Name No. of votes
----------------------------------------
1. Jimly Asshiddiqie 37
2. Achmad Rustandi 26
3. I Dewa Gede Palguna 22
4. Dahlan Thaib 18
5. Harun Kamil 15
6. M. Fajrul Falaakh 10
7. Ali Hardi Kiaidemak 6
8. Edith Nababan 5
9. Benjamin Mangkoedilaga 2
10. I Dewa Gede Atmadja 1
11. Soebagyo 1
12. Eko Sugitario -
----------------------------------------
Source: House Commission II