Factions split over 4 million civil servants

Factions split over 4 million civil servants

JAKARTA (JP): Factions on the House of Representatives'
Working Committee were divided into two camps over whether
Indonesia's 4 million civil servants should be allowed to be
involved in political parties.

Danial Tandjung of the United Development Party (PPP) said the
committee's closed session on Friday ended in a deadlock. The
legislators eventually agreed to seek a breakthrough by
consulting their leaderships and lobbying among them.

"The working committee's session will resume on Monday and all
factions are expected to have reached agreement on the crucial
issue by then," he said.

Danial said that the PPP, the Indonesian Democratic Party
(PDI) and Armed Forces (ABRI) factions wanted the civil servants
to be neutral, while major faction Golkar wanted them to be
allowed membership of political parties.

Djufrie Asmoredjo, chairman of the working committee
deliberating the draft law on political parties, warned of
"widely negative impacts" arising from civil servants'
participation in political parties.

For instance, they could discriminate against certain groups
needing their services, Djufrie said.

In addition, "civil servants from non-ruling parties may face
difficulties in developing their career and ABRI (Armed Forces),
which is of the same status as the civil servant corps, will also
demand that they are allowed to be involved in political
parties," said Djufrie.

Yahya Zaini of Golkar said civil servants are Indonesian
citizens with political rights. "Barring them from political
activities is against human rights," he said.

Yahya also dismissed the PPP faction's warning that the civil
servants corps should be separated from ABRI since the latter was
assigned to be in charge of defense and security.

Besides, defining civil servants' neutrality as barring them
from politics did not guarantee a democratic government, he said.

He cited how civil servants in Thailand can join political
parties and how its government was more democratic than
Indonesia's.

Under former president Soeharto's New Order regime, civil
servants were forced to be loyal to and to vote only for Golkar.

The government-sponsored bill seeks to bar civil servants and
servicemen from joining political parties, saying they have the
right to vote but not to be elected.

Meanwhile, in a concurrent session of the working committee in
charge of deliberating the structure of legislative bodies,
legislators again failed to break through a deadlock over the
presence of the military in the House of Representatives (DPR).

Budi Harsono, chairman of the working committee, said all
factions were expected to reconsider their stance on the matter
in order to enable the committee to reach a win-win solution.

"This is a very crucial issue and all factions have their own
stands which are difficult to bridge," he acknowledged.

Harminto Agustono of PPP insisted his faction would fight so
ABRI can have only two percent or ten House seats.

"We will defend the current size of the DPR and we will fight
for a decrease of ABRI representatives in the House from the
current 75 to only 10 in the 1999-2004 period," he said.

If the factions failed to reach a common stance, the issue
should just be settled through a vote, he said.

Golkar has proposed five to 10 percent of 500 seats at the
House for appointed ABRI representatives while PDI is still
undecided over the issue.

ABRI supported the draft law which proposed 10 percent of the
proposed 550 seats in the House to allow it to play a role again
in the coming period. (rms)