Debating the debate

Some parts of the bill on general elections can be considered quite sensitive or controversial, but nonetheless necessary, while there are other bits being debated that are virtually meaningless and should be dropped altogether.

Among the articles which need serious attention are those on the public debates for presidential candidates, as well as the one barring government officials from participating in election campaigns. These two parts, in addition to the less important ones, have forced the delay in the passing of the bill into law.

The presidential candidate debates are being rejected only by the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI Perjuangan).

The PDI Perjuangan objection, whether it is stated or not, is quite obviously related to their 2004 candidate, President Megawati Soekarnoputri, and her apparent aversion to public speaking and debating.

From the past to the present, Mega has never been accustomed to having an open dialog, much less a debate. Mega, who is considered to be quite competent in her own way by her supporters, has always regarded silence as the best way to manage her government.

A leader, if it is passed, will now have to speak frequently, hold dialogs and offer clear explanations on a range of issues.

The party or candidate who rejects such a debate should not get any support from the people.

-- Media Indonesia, Jakarta

Garuda pilot's strike

We are relieved to learn that the pilots of the Indonesian flag carrier, Garuda, have canceled their plan to go on strike. We appreciate the decision of the pilots, who are grouped in the Garuda Pilots Association. Each job must have a public service function.

This function is extremely vital for Garuda Indonesia. Imagine if Garuda flights stopped due to the strike. The mobility of passengers who fly for government and business trips would come to a halt.

There would not only be material losses but other losses as well.

How can it be possible for such a vital group of people exercise its right to stage a strike? It would only worsen its public service.

Everybody should be expected to uphold the public interest.

-- Kompas, Jakarta