'Cash aid make people lazy'

The government raised fuel prices on Oct. 1 after putting into place a scheme that allocates low-income families Rp 100,000 a month to alleviate the extra financial burden they must bear. The Jakarta Post asked residents their opinion about the issue.

Annisa, 22, works as a public relations officer for a foreign company. She lives with her brother in Meruya, West Jakarta:

I agree that fuel prices had to be increased as long as the government gives poor people sufficient cash assistant. I think Rp 100,000 per month is far from enough considering the sharp increase in the prices of basic needs, such as food and clothing.

The assistance should be Rp 300,000 per month to minimize the impact of the higher prices on poor people. I know many would argue that the government doesn't have the money, but if that's the case it should find it or step aside.

In addition, considering the corruption committed by officials in the past, I doubt the money will reach its targets. If any money does reach the poor, it will probably be far less than the monthly Rp 100,000 allotted to each family. I propose that a special monitoring team be established at once.

Wisudanto C. Suntoyo, 30, works at the World Trade Center. He lives with his wife and child in Bintaro, Tangerang:

How can we be sure that the data for fuel compensation cards is accurate? The procedure for the national census should be questioned. The fact is that people can easily obtain official identification cards through illegal means.

Also the concept of a welfare scheme like this -- giving people money -- will only encourage laziness. After all, people don't need to work for the money.

-- The Jakarta Post