Belo's article biased
Belo's article biased
I was disgusted by the article written by Bishop Carlos Filipe
Ximenes Belo, Why the world owes my people (Newsweek, Oct. 4,
1999). Almost all the stories told by Belo were total lies and
extremely biased.
* Indonesia did not invade East Timor in 1975. The Indonesian
Army entered East Timor on the invitation of the warring factions
to help restore order and curtail the civil war there, which
erupted after the Portuguese left the island. That was the first
time the Timorese breathed the air of freedom in East Timor,
after more than 450 years under the yoke of the wicked Portuguese
rule.
* It is not true that 200,000 people were killed in East Timor.
* The Indonesian Army saved the Timorese by allowing them safe-
passage to the Indonesian territory of Kupang after violence
erupted following the Aug. 30 ballot there. These people are now
given a free choice either to return to East Timor or stay in
Indonesia. Their return to East Timor is in progress now, with
people being transported by plane from Kupang to Dili.
* The Army Special Force was not in East Timor.
* The Indonesian Military never obstructed relief operations in
East Timor, but rather they fully supported them.
* The killing of Sander Thoenes and Indonesian journalist Agus
were the full responsibility of Major Gen. Peter Cosgrove and his
Australian troops.
* Bishop Belo now seems to love the Timorese. Where was he and
what did he do to help the Timorese when they were under
Portuguese rule?
* When the Timorese were freed by the Indonesians in 1974/1975,
they were no more than coolies and East Timor was extremely
underdeveloped.
* It is the Indonesian people who helped them become human beings
in the true sense of the word. It was Indonesia which gave
freedom to them. No nation in the world can deny this.
Finally, I would like to mention that nearly all of Newsweek's
news reports and stories regarding East Timor were unfair toward
the Indonesian government, the Indonesian people and the
Indonesian Army in particular. I wonder what kind of code of
conduct they practice. I have been subscribing to Newsweek for
nearly a year now, but all of its stories about my country are
biased and degrading.
MUHD. RAMZY HASIBUAN
Jakarta