A problem of communication
The phrase "Ciganjur Group" is used to circumvent the use of the word opposition, which is still abhorred in our political and official vernacular. This group -- which in the context of Sunday's meeting with (Armed Forces Commander Gen.) Wiranto acquired the additional word "plus" because of the presence of (Moslem intellectual) Nurcholish Madjid -- is a representation, and at the same time a personification of the collective conscience of those who have been left out -- not to say locked out -- of government.
Unique is perhaps the position of Sultan Hamengku Buwono X in the Ciganjur Group. Being the governor of the Special Area of Yogyakarta, what is he doing in this group? Could his inclusion have been meant to lend legitimacy to what would otherwise be an obnoxious opposition? Judging by the Sultan's stance and actions it would seem that he is fully aware of his position and that his joining the group was deliberate. This would signify that he wants change and is at the same time anticipating change.
Then there was Nurcholish Madjid, a scholar who is known for his integrity. Whether intentional or not, his presence in the Ciganjur Group strengthens this nongovernmental component. There are many other people like Nurcholish who need to be made aware of the fact that they too possess authority. It is people like Nurcholish whom those with political interests are at present tirelessly courting.
The political dimensions (of the meeting) could be wide and complex if one were to analyze the event. The meeting took place at a stage where the idea of a national dialog or a national reconciliation has already been adamantly rejected by the government. It was held with the Ciganjur-Plus Group, which is the most significant pressure group at the moment.
As far as we are concerned, the more often government and nongovernment leaders meet, the better, especially if the crucial problems of the nation are part of the discussions. Communication and interaction among our fellow citizens must not be limited to legal forums -- such as in the House of Representatives or through general elections -- only. This nation's most critical obstacle lies in its inability to find a compromise to settle crucial problems.
-- Media Indonesia, Jakarta