Mon, 14 Mar 2005

Will a Muslim woman ever be more than what she wears?

Mona Eltahawy The Daily Star Asia News Network Dhaka

Shabina Begum, a 16-year-old Muslim schoolgirl who won the right on Wednesday to wear a jilbab to her school in the British town of Luton told the British newspaper The Guardian that she felt like screaming with happiness when she heard the court decision.

I felt like screaming with anger and frustration when I heard about Shabina's case because once again a Muslim woman is in the headlines only because of what she wears. When will this madness end?

Shabina's school did not prevent her from wearing a headscarf. Unlike French schools which have banned the hijab outright, Shabina's school went out of its way to accommodate the needs of students who are nearly 80 percent Muslim, speak 40 different languages and who are from 21 different ethnic groups.

Students could wear the regular uniform or they could wear a shalwar kameez. They could wear a headscarf as long as it conformed to certain criteria. In order to satisfy the needs of the diverse background of its students, the school consulted with pupils, parents, schools and leading Muslim organizations when it was formulating its uniform policy.

And yet this was not enough for Shabina who wore the shalwar kameez from the time she enrolled at the school when she was 12 until September 2002 when she suddenly decided to wear the jilbab, a long loose fitting one-piece item that covers the body from head to ankles.

Her school refused to allow her to attend until she resumed wearing the approved uniform. Shabina took the school to court but her case was rejected by High Court judges last summer. The school had argued that allowing her to wear a jilbab would impact on the rights of other Muslim girl pupils who opposed allowing the jilbab as they felt that it would create a hierarchy of belief at the school.

Her school was right. What has become of our faith that it has turned into a competition over who can cover the most? Who convinces young Muslim women that they must cover more and more, going far beyond what is deemed the modest clothing that Islam requires of men and women?

Shabina switched to a school that allowed her to wear the jilbab and her case went to the Court of Appeal which on Wednesday agreed that her initial school had a right to set a school uniform policy but that it had failed to consider Shabina's rights under the Human Rights Act.

The Guardian reported that Lord Justice Brooke, vice-president of the civil division of the court of appeal, ruled that Shabina's school had: Unlawfully excluded her; unlawfully denied her the right to manifest her religion; unlawfully denied her access to suitable and appropriate education.

Lord Justice Brooke has committed the simplest mistake that a non-Muslim commits -- he accepted at face value the assertion by Shabina and her lawyers that the jilbab, an especially strict interpretation of modest dress, was a requirement for Muslim women. To this day, Muslim scholars issue various interpretations about Muslim dress. After the Sept. 11 attacks, some Muslim scholars in the America even told Muslim women they did not have to wear a headscarf if they felt in danger from anti-Muslim attacks.

Shabina chose to go beyond a uniform that was deemed acceptable for the other Muslims and denied herself the ability to continue attending her school. She claimed that her school's refusal to allow her to attend classes in a jilbab was a result of post-Sept. 11 bigotry. I assert that Lord Justice Brooke's ruling is a classic example of liberal guilt over the ugly Islamophobia that many Muslims have faced since Sept. 11. Instead of standing up to a growing conservatism among some Muslims, many liberals will simply give in rather than appear prejudiced. Sadly, most of the points they give in on have to do with Muslim women.

This is nothing short of the racism of lower expectations -- they expect Muslims to be extreme, they expect Muslim women to be covered. The Guardian newspaper, which I reported for from the Middle East, committed a grave error in reporting Shabina's story. It did not interview a single Muslim woman who could have told them there is more to being a Muslim than a jilbab and that such a jilbab was over and beyond what is deemed modest.

Interestingly, Shabina was represented by Cherie Booth, the wife of British Prime Minister Tony Blair. Some Muslims might see something to celebrate in this and say, "Look, the wife of the British prime minister is defending a Muslim girl's rights." There is no need for celebration.

I wish Cherie Booth had defended a Muslim girl's right to complete her education against a family who was pulling her out of school early to get married, which happens even in Britain. I wish she had defended a Muslim girl against violence at home -- a suffering that is too often ignored by the Muslim community in the West because it would prefer girls and women suffer in silence than bring shame to the community by speaking out.

And what does Shabina think she has achieved? She told The Guardian that the Court of Appeal verdict would "give hope and strength to other Muslim women" and that it was a victory for all Muslims "who wish to preserve their identity and values despite prejudice and bigotry."

My response to Shabina is thanks but no thanks. I wore the hijab for nine years from the age of 16 to 25 and do not feel my identity lies in a piece of cloth. I gain my hope and strength by sharing the excitement of ambitious young Muslim women like my sister Noora who loves her university studies. Noora wears the hijab but she knows that it is what is in her head, not what is on it that is more important.

The writer is a New York-based columnist for the pan-Arab Asharq al-Awsat newspaper.





News Search/Filter
Transaction Rates
16 Aug 18
Buy
Sell
AED1
3,904.98
3,904.98
AFN1
196.77
196.77
ALL1
129.39
129.39
AMD1
29.73
29.73
ANG1
7,772.77
7,772.77
AOA1
53.35
53.35
ARS1
482.14
482.14
AUD1
10,375.77
10,375.77
AWG1
7,995.37
7,995.37
AZN1
8,425.09
8,425.09
BAM1
8,299.56
8,299.56
BBD1
7,171.86
7,171.86
BDT1
169.71
169.71
BGN1
8,319.73
8,319.73
BHD1
38,038.03
38,038.03
BIF1
8.10
8.10
BMD1
14,343.72
14,343.72
BND1
9,493.49
9,493.49
BOB1
2,075.83
2,075.83
BRL1
3,675.14
3,675.14
BSD1
14,343.72
14,343.72
BTC1
90,527,612
90,527,612
BTN1
205.12
205.12
BWP1
1,324.36
1,324.36
BYN1
6,969.22
6,969.22
BZD1
7,134.69
7,134.69
CAD1
10,909.89
10,909.89
CDF1
8.81
8.81
CHF1
14,437.67
14,437.67
CLF1
613,504.02
613,504.02
CLP1
21.48
21.48
CNH1
2,065.99
2,065.99
CNY1
2,068.08
2,068.08
COP1
4.76
4.76
CRC1
25.27
25.27
CUC1
14,343.72
14,343.72
CUP1
562.49
562.49
CVE1
147.19
147.19
CZK1
631.41
631.41
DJF1
80.56
80.56
DKK1
2,182.21
2,182.21
DOP1
287.50
287.50
DZD1
120.29
120.29
EGP1
801.50
801.50
ERN1
956.45
956.45
ETB1
519.14
519.14
EUR1
16,267.66
16,267.66
FJD1
6,765.74
6,765.74
FKP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
GBP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
GEL1
5,780.22
5,780.22
GGP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
GHS1
2,943.81
2,943.81
GIP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
GMD1
297.89
297.89
GNF1
1.58
1.58
GTQ1
1,913.77
1,913.77
GYD1
68.67
68.67
HKD1
1,827.29
1,827.29
HNL1
596.66
596.66
HRK1
2,190.41
2,190.41
HTG1
212.81
212.81
HUF1
50.12
50.12
IDR1
1.00
1.00
ILS1
3,892.81
3,892.81
IMP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
INR1
204.10
204.10
IQD1
12.03
12.03
IRR1
0.33
0.33
ISK1
131.24
131.24
JEP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
JMD1
105.56
105.56
JOD1
20,216.57
20,216.57
JPY1
129.72
129.72
KES1
142.30
142.30
KGS1
210.51
210.51
KHR1
3.52
3.52
KMF1
33.06
33.06
KPW1
15.93
15.93
KRW1
12.61
12.61
KWD1
47,280.81
47,280.81
KYD1
17,207.68
17,207.68
KZT1
39.64
39.64
LAK1
1.68
1.68
LBP1
9.49
9.49
LKR1
89.54
89.54
LRD1
93.32
93.32
LSL1
1,006.22
1,006.22
LYD1
10,276.86
10,276.86
MAD1
1,497.80
1,497.80
MDL1
864.13
864.13
MGA1
4.31
4.31
MKD1
264.18
264.18
MMK1
9.47
9.47
MNT1
5.87
5.87
MOP1
1,773.66
1,773.66
MRO1
40.12
40.12
MRU1
398.99
398.99
MUR1
412.17
412.17
MVR1
927.19
927.19
MWK1
19.72
19.72
MXN1
747.55
747.55
MYR1
3,495.48
3,495.48
MZN1
245.52
245.52
NAD1
1,005.51
1,005.51
NGN1
39.74
39.74
NIO1
447.89
447.89
NOK1
1,695.20
1,695.20
NPR1
128.20
128.20
NZD1
9,405.39
9,405.39
OMR1
37,254.49
37,254.49
PAB1
14,343.72
14,343.72
PEN1
4,323.00
4,323.00
PGK1
4,328.25
4,328.25
PHP1
267.88
267.88
PKR1
116.12
116.12
PLN1
3,764.23
3,764.23
PYG1
2.49
2.49
QAR1
3,939.43
3,939.43
RON1
3,487.43
3,487.43
RSD1
137.90
137.90
RUB1
213.05
213.05
RWF1
16.33
16.33
SAR1
3,823.97
3,823.97
SBD1
1,818.16
1,818.16
SCR1
1,055.33
1,055.33
SDG1
796.69
796.69
SEK1
1,557.02
1,557.02
SGD1
10,392.95
10,392.95
SHP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
SLL1
2.19
2.19
SOS1
24.79
24.79
SRD1
1,923.26
1,923.26
SSP1
110.11
110.11
STD1
0.68
0.68
STN1
660.54
660.54
SVC1
1,638.95
1,638.95
SYP1
27.85
27.85
SZL1
984.80
984.80
THB1
430.35
430.35
TJS1
1,522.29
1,522.29
TMT1
4,098.23
4,098.23
TND1
5,154.61
5,154.61
TOP1
6,207.95
6,207.95
TRY1
2,398.64
2,398.64
TTD1
2,127.88
2,127.88
TWD1
465.08
465.08
TZS1
6.28
6.28
UAH1
522.33
522.33
UGX1
3.83
3.83
USD1
14,343.72
14,343.72
UYU1
457.87
457.87
UZS1
1.84
1.84
VEF1
0.10
0.10
VND1
0.62
0.62
VUV1
132.20
132.20
WST1
5,541.25
5,541.25
XAF1
24.79
24.79
XAG1
211,784.47
211,784.47
XAU1
17,028,223.52
17,028,223.52
XCD1
5,307.47
5,307.47
XDR1
19,983.25
19,983.25
XOF1
24.79
24.79
XPD1
14,201,707.01
14,201,707.01
XPF1
136.32
136.32
XPT1
11,291,959.19
11,291,959.19
YER1
57.28
57.28
ZAR1
984.89
984.89
ZMW1
1,405.97
1,405.97
ZWL1
44.49
44.49
Taxation Exchange Rates
31 Aug 16 - 06 Sep 16
USD 1
13,232.00
AUD 1
10,043.30
CAD 1
10,213.70
DKK 1
1,999.40
HKD 1
1,706.22
MYR 1
3,283.28
NZD 1
9,623.63
NOK 1
1,605.23
GBP 1
17,433.70
SGD 1
9,757.68
SEK 1
1,569.45
CHF 1
13,631.10
JPY 100
13,101.00
MMK 1
11.01
INR 1
197.29
KWD 1
43,920.70
PKR 1
126.23
PHP 1
285.00
SAR 1
3,528.53
LKR 1
91.12
THB 1
382.08
BND 1
9,756.53
EUR 1
14,885.50
CNY 1
1,987.61

Okusi Associates: Indonesian Business & Management Services