Fri, 11 Mar 2005

Old problems, new burdens

Every time the government raises domestic fuel prices closer to their real economic cost, businesspeople always raise a rumpus, urging the government to deal firmly with the old problems of red tape, illegal levies, and corrupt tax and customs services to offset the additional burden on business.

This was also the case after the March 1 fuel price hikes. Most businesses argue they will not be able to remain competitive under the new environment of higher fuel prices if the government does not act immediately to cut other costs related to government regulations and public services.

The Riau chapter of the Indonesian Employers Association notified economics ministers last week that 24 more foreign investors on Batam island had threatened to pull out due to the worsening business climate and the uncertainty over that island's free-trade status.

The complainants are not skittish investors who are demanding special facilities or preferential treatment. Their grievances are legitimate as they have found that their international competitiveness is being eroded by an inimical business climate. Now, higher fuel prices are imposing additional burdens on them.

The government should fully realize why the competitive edge of our economy has steadily been declining. Many studies have diagnosed the problems and made policy recommendations. But the leadership and political will of the new government seem to not be as strong as the political mandate it received in last year's presidential election.

Indonesia consistently performs abysmally in all international surveys of economic competitiveness and invariably ranks far below all of the other founding members of ASEAN. The 2004 Economic Freedom of the World Report, which was prepared by Canada's Fraser Institute last July, ranked Indonesia 86th out of the 123 countries assessed in terms of good governance, access to sound money, freedom to trade internationally, regulations on credit, and labor and business, legal structures and security of property rights.

Indonesia also ranked very low in both indices of the Global Competitiveness Report 2003, which was prepared and issued by the Geneva-based World Economic Forum. It was rated 66th out of 102 countries surveyed in the growth competitiveness index and 58th in the business competitiveness index.

Overall, businesses in Indonesia shoulder almost twice as much in administrative costs and have to struggle through twice as arduous bureaucratic procedures as their counterparts in other ASEAN countries.

The higher business risks and gross inefficiency in Indonesia can, for example, be seen from the much higher terminal handling charges (THC) for containers charged by foreign shipping companies at Indonesian ports than at other ports in ASEAN countries. For example, the THC for a 20-foot container in an Indonesian port is set at US$150, as against $110 in Singapore, $100 in Malaysia and a mere $60 in Thailand, the latest data from the Far Eastern Shipping Conference shows.

The government needs to take a more strategic view of all the weaknesses of our economy, and realign its list of priorities with the focus on creating a sound business environment so as to woo new domestic and foreign investment.

Pointless regulations foster corruption. The more irksome the rule, the greater the incentive to bribe officials not to enforce it. Red tape is one of the chief obstacles to growth in almost all poor countries.

There is much that governments can do to promote reform even when lacking a clear mandate for wide-ranging action, let alone the current government which possesses such a strong a political mandate.

Moving ahead in areas where the basis for reform has been best prepared and laying the groundwork for further reform by setting out to shape, or reshape, popular understandings of the issues would inspire business confidence about the direction of the country's economic management.

Laggards sometimes argue that reforms are difficult and costly to enact. But what could be simpler than scrapping a stupid rule? Simplifying procedures is harder, but not too hard. There are plenty of examples to learn from.

It needs to be remembered that it's a vicious circle -- an economy can never be competitive if its businesses are not productive, while its businesses will never be productive if the investment climate is not supportive.

--------





News Search/Filter
Transaction Rates
17 Aug 18
Buy
Sell
AED1
3,905.20
3,905.20
AFN1
196.97
196.97
ALL1
129.72
129.72
AMD1
29.70
29.70
ANG1
7,779.22
7,779.22
AOA1
53.05
53.05
ARS1
482.59
482.59
AUD1
10,412.68
10,412.68
AWG1
8,002.51
8,002.51
AZN1
8,425.56
8,425.56
BAM1
8,339.10
8,339.10
BBD1
7,172.25
7,172.25
BDT1
169.85
169.85
BGN1
8,340.36
8,340.36
BHD1
38,040.23
38,040.23
BIF1
8.09
8.09
BMD1
14,344.51
14,344.51
BND1
9,494.90
9,494.90
BOB1
2,076.34
2,076.34
BRL1
3,672.98
3,672.98
BSD1
14,344.51
14,344.51
BTC1
93,023,996
93,023,996
BTN1
204.19
204.19
BWP1
1,327.51
1,327.51
BYN1
6,985.73
6,985.73
BZD1
7,140.60
7,140.60
CAD1
10,899.67
10,899.67
CDF1
8.81
8.81
CHF1
14,382.14
14,382.14
CLF1
613,537.92
613,537.92
CLP1
21.43
21.43
CNH1
2,088.40
2,088.40
CNY1
2,083.70
2,083.70
COP1
4.70
4.70
CRC1
25.29
25.29
CUC1
14,344.51
14,344.51
CUP1
562.53
562.53
CVE1
147.42
147.42
CZK1
633.80
633.80
DJF1
80.58
80.58
DKK1
2,187.63
2,187.63
DOP1
287.60
287.60
DZD1
120.51
120.51
EGP1
801.28
801.28
ERN1
956.52
956.52
ETB1
520.33
520.33
EUR1
16,312.52
16,312.52
FJD1
6,776.17
6,776.17
FKP1
18,235.54
18,235.54
GBP1
18,235.54
18,235.54
GEL1
5,777.74
5,777.74
GGP1
18,235.54
18,235.54
GHS1
2,942.99
2,942.99
GIP1
18,235.54
18,235.54
GMD1
297.85
297.85
GNF1
1.58
1.58
GTQ1
1,915.30
1,915.30
GYD1
68.60
68.60
HKD1
1,827.39
1,827.39
HNL1
596.94
596.94
HRK1
2,197.51
2,197.51
HTG1
212.99
212.99
HUF1
50.35
50.35
IDR1
1.00
1.00
ILS1
3,907.23
3,907.23
IMP1
18,235.54
18,235.54
INR1
204.87
204.87
IQD1
12.03
12.03
IRR1
0.33
0.33
ISK1
132.41
132.41
JEP1
18,235.54
18,235.54
JMD1
105.79
105.79
JOD1
20,217.69
20,217.69
JPY1
129.21
129.21
KES1
142.32
142.32
KGS1
210.52
210.52
KHR1
3.52
3.52
KMF1
33.13
33.13
KPW1
15.93
15.93
KRW1
12.72
12.72
KWD1
47,291.38
47,291.38
KYD1
17,222.41
17,222.41
KZT1
39.84
39.84
LAK1
1.68
1.68
LBP1
9.49
9.49
LKR1
89.42
89.42
LRD1
92.81
92.81
LSL1
1,006.27
1,006.27
LYD1
10,301.69
10,301.69
MAD1
1,499.65
1,499.65
MDL1
862.45
862.45
MGA1
4.31
4.31
MKD1
264.97
264.97
MMK1
9.39
9.39
MNT1
5.87
5.87
MOP1
1,775.17
1,775.17
MRO1
40.12
40.12
MRU1
399.01
399.01
MUR1
411.60
411.60
MVR1
927.84
927.84
MWK1
19.72
19.72
MXN1
755.05
755.05
MYR1
3,493.97
3,493.97
MZN1
243.17
243.17
NAD1
986.73
986.73
NGN1
39.73
39.73
NIO1
450.07
450.07
NOK1
1,691.33
1,691.33
NPR1
127.61
127.61
NZD1
9,443.94
9,443.94
OMR1
37,262.35
37,262.35
PAB1
14,344.51
14,344.51
PEN1
4,331.07
4,331.07
PGK1
4,331.66
4,331.66
PHP1
268.49
268.49
PKR1
116.85
116.85
PLN1
3,788.58
3,788.58
PYG1
2.49
2.49
QAR1
3,939.64
3,939.64
RON1
3,501.99
3,501.99
RSD1
138.24
138.24
RUB1
214.51
214.51
RWF1
16.34
16.34
SAR1
3,824.49
3,824.49
SBD1
1,818.26
1,818.26
SCR1
1,055.61
1,055.61
SDG1
797.35
797.35
SEK1
1,560.13
1,560.13
SGD1
10,425.93
10,425.93
SHP1
18,235.54
18,235.54
SLL1
2.19
2.19
SOS1
24.80
24.80
SRD1
1,923.37
1,923.37
SSP1
110.11
110.11
STD1
0.68
0.68
STN1
664.86
664.86
SVC1
1,640.18
1,640.18
SYP1
27.85
27.85
SZL1
986.74
986.74
THB1
432.12
432.12
TJS1
1,522.82
1,522.82
TMT1
4,086.80
4,086.80
TND1
5,178.91
5,178.91
TOP1
6,208.30
6,208.30
TRY1
2,451.13
2,451.13
TTD1
2,129.41
2,129.41
TWD1
466.32
466.32
TZS1
6.27
6.27
UAH1
519.35
519.35
UGX1
3.82
3.82
USD1
14,344.51
14,344.51
UYU1
454.32
454.32
UZS1
1.84
1.84
VEF1
0.10
0.10
VND1
0.62
0.62
VUV1
132.20
132.20
WST1
5,541.56
5,541.56
XAF1
24.86
24.86
XAG1
211,794.36
211,794.36
XAU1
17,029,164.34
17,029,164.34
XCD1
5,307.77
5,307.77
XDR1
20,003.03
20,003.03
XOF1
24.86
24.86
XPD1
14,202,491.66
14,202,491.66
XPF1
136.69
136.69
XPT1
11,287,962.18
11,287,962.18
YER1
57.30
57.30
ZAR1
984.95
984.95
ZMW1
1,403.71
1,403.71
ZWL1
44.49
44.49
Taxation Exchange Rates
31 Aug 16 - 06 Sep 16
USD 1
13,232.00
AUD 1
10,043.30
CAD 1
10,213.70
DKK 1
1,999.40
HKD 1
1,706.22
MYR 1
3,283.28
NZD 1
9,623.63
NOK 1
1,605.23
GBP 1
17,433.70
SGD 1
9,757.68
SEK 1
1,569.45
CHF 1
13,631.10
JPY 100
13,101.00
MMK 1
11.01
INR 1
197.29
KWD 1
43,920.70
PKR 1
126.23
PHP 1
285.00
SAR 1
3,528.53
LKR 1
91.12
THB 1
382.08
BND 1
9,756.53
EUR 1
14,885.50
CNY 1
1,987.61

Okusi Associates: Indonesian Business & Management Services