Mon, 07 Mar 2005

Monitoring court officials could wipe out corruption

The Jakarta Post, Jakarta

"Thieves for their robbery have authority when judges steal themselves," Shakespeare, the famous English bard, once said.

The words, which were expressed by a man who lived more than 400 years ago, still ring true in Indonesia today, with the judicial system widely regarded as one of the most corrupt institutions in the country.

"The courts have been one of the government institutions that have given rise to the most complaints from the public. The complaints are still coming in thick and fast," Masdar Farid Mas'udi of the National Ombudsman Commission (KON) told The Jakarta Post on Saturday.

The recently published Asian Development Bank (ADB)'s Government Assessment Report 2005-Indonesia states that almost 36 percent of the complaints received by the KON in its first year of operation were related to judicial corruption.

The KON was established on March 20, 2000, based on Presidential Decree No.44/2000 for the purpose of monitoring the performance of state institutions in providing services to the public.

According to the report, the rampant corruption in the country's judicial system involves both judges, the ultimate decision makers in the judicial system, and clerks. Inadequate funding is often cited as the main excuse.

The multinational lender said that Indonesia spent only around 0.3 percent of its annual state budget on funding the country's more than 700 courts, 2,910 judges and 10,000 clerks. Many other countries typically devoted about 2 percent of their budgetary spending to the courts.

"It is normal for officials of the courts to demand illicit payments to expedite the hearing and adjudication of cases. More worrisome for the cause of justice is the extent of corruption that affects the decisions of the court," the ADB report said.

The country's weak and corrupt judicial system has been one of the main factors seen to be hampering badly needed new investment in the country.

A young lawyer who requested anonymity confirmed the findings and said that the rampant corruption involved lawyers, prosecutors, and court clerks, collectively known as the "court mafia".

"There are several modes of corruption involving the judges. I know of several famous lawyers who pay monthly allowances to a number of judges in the administrative courts," the lawyer told the Post.

He said there were two typical ways in which judges were bribed. First was to negotiate the verdict, or what lawyers called a "bombing" or "auction", while the second most common way was to give the judges gifts after winning the case.

The ADB report also mentioned other practices such as the paying off of a court president to influence the selection of the judges who would hear a case. The payoff could take the form, for example, of a payment toward the judge's son's or daughter's wedding or for the purchase of a car or a house.

The young lawyer also shared his experiences of paying off clerks to get legal documentation for his client.

"If I want to get a document declaring that your clients is not involved in a trial process, which is really needed by companies, I have to pay them Rp 500,000 for each document. This is a non-negotiable fee," he said.

He said that both the judges and clerks then shared the illicit money with other officials working in the court system.

A clerk in the South Jakarta District Court denied the allegations, arguing that the clerks' duties were only to support the work of the judges and that therefore they had no power to influence decisions.

Masdar suggested that effective monitoring should be conducted by the Supreme Court or a Judicial Commission to stop the rampant bribery and that the public should report all incidences of illegal conduct in the courts. (006)





News Search/Filter
Transaction Rates
17 Oct 18
Buy
Sell
AED1
4,141.07
4,141.07
AFN1
200.00
200.00
ALL1
140.59
140.59
AMD1
31.42
31.42
ANG1
8,569.33
8,569.33
AOA1
50.52
50.52
ARS1
423.53
423.53
AUD1
10,858.36
10,858.36
AWG1
8,448.12
8,448.12
AZN1
8,934.44
8,934.44
BAM1
9,004.48
9,004.48
BBD1
7,605.45
7,605.45
BDT1
179.57
179.57
BGN1
9,003.57
9,003.57
BHD1
40,350.42
40,350.42
BIF1
8.49
8.49
BMD1
15,210.90
15,210.90
BND1
10,785.86
10,785.86
BOB1
2,200.85
2,200.85
BRL1
4,083.13
4,083.13
BSD1
15,210.90
15,210.90
BTC1
97,397,904
97,397,904
BTN1
206.69
206.69
BWP1
1,429.32
1,429.32
BYN1
7,214.06
7,214.06
BZD1
7,568.80
7,568.80
CAD1
11,758.18
11,758.18
CDF1
9.31
9.31
CHF1
15,357.25
15,357.25
CLF1
607,270.04
607,270.04
CLP1
22.74
22.74
CNH1
2,200.65
2,200.65
CNY1
2,200.64
2,200.64
COP1
4.91
4.91
CRC1
25.61
25.61
CUC1
15,210.90
15,210.90
CUP1
590.71
590.71
CVE1
159.44
159.44
CZK1
681.55
681.55
DJF1
85.45
85.45
DKK1
2,360.18
2,360.18
DOP1
304.54
304.54
DZD1
128.68
128.68
EGP1
849.34
849.34
ERN1
1,014.18
1,014.18
ETB1
545.75
545.75
EUR1
17,609.16
17,609.16
FJD1
7,139.77
7,139.77
FKP1
20,059.76
20,059.76
GBP1
20,059.76
20,059.76
GEL1
6,188.94
6,188.94
GGP1
20,059.76
20,059.76
GHS1
3,137.58
3,137.58
GIP1
20,059.76
20,059.76
GMD1
307.55
307.55
GNF1
1.67
1.67
GTQ1
1,968.42
1,968.42
GYD1
72.76
72.76
HKD1
1,940.85
1,940.85
HNL1
631.87
631.87
HRK1
2,374.42
2,374.42
HTG1
213.80
213.80
HUF1
54.70
54.70
IDR1
1.00
1.00
ILS1
4,177.22
4,177.22
IMP1
20,059.76
20,059.76
INR1
207.04
207.04
IQD1
12.76
12.76
IRR1
0.35
0.35
ISK1
128.88
128.88
JEP1
20,059.76
20,059.76
JMD1
113.78
113.78
JOD1
21,438.80
21,438.80
JPY1
135.39
135.39
KES1
150.69
150.69
KGS1
221.92
221.92
KHR1
3.72
3.72
KMF1
35.79
35.79
KPW1
16.90
16.90
KRW1
13.54
13.54
KWD1
50,187.90
50,187.90
KYD1
18,253.04
18,253.04
KZT1
41.42
41.42
LAK1
1.78
1.78
LBP1
10.07
10.07
LKR1
89.02
89.02
LRD1
96.88
96.88
LSL1
1,054.49
1,054.49
LYD1
10,999.87
10,999.87
MAD1
1,611.46
1,611.46
MDL1
892.72
892.72
MGA1
4.29
4.29
MKD1
286.31
286.31
MMK1
9.50
9.50
MNT1
6.11
6.11
MOP1
1,884.09
1,884.09
MRO1
42.60
42.60
MRU1
423.70
423.70
MUR1
442.82
442.82
MVR1
984.52
984.52
MWK1
20.91
20.91
MXN1
811.05
811.05
MYR1
3,662.25
3,662.25
MZN1
251.38
251.38
NAD1
1,054.02
1,054.02
NGN1
41.81
41.81
NIO1
473.40
473.40
NOK1
1,867.72
1,867.72
NPR1
129.18
129.18
NZD1
10,014.09
10,014.09
OMR1
39,511.39
39,511.39
PAB1
15,210.90
15,210.90
PEN1
4,565.70
4,565.70
PGK1
4,534.33
4,534.33
PHP1
282.56
282.56
PKR1
115.16
115.16
PLN1
4,107.61
4,107.61
PYG1
2.55
2.55
QAR1
4,177.67
4,177.67
RON1
3,773.49
3,773.49
RSD1
149.01
149.01
RUB1
232.85
232.85
RWF1
17.28
17.28
SAR1
4,054.77
4,054.77
SBD1
1,916.18
1,916.18
SCR1
1,116.88
1,116.88
SDG1
322.30
322.30
SEK1
1,707.13
1,707.13
SGD1
11,066.47
11,066.47
SHP1
20,059.76
20,059.76
SLL1
1.81
1.81
SOS1
26.27
26.27
SRD1
2,039.54
2,039.54
SSP1
116.77
116.77
STD1
0.72
0.72
STN1
716.81
716.81
SVC1
1,738.55
1,738.55
SYP1
29.53
29.53
SZL1
1,056.27
1,056.27
THB1
468.00
468.00
TJS1
1,613.89
1,613.89
TMT1
4,345.98
4,345.98
TND1
5,385.33
5,385.33
TOP1
6,596.53
6,596.53
TRY1
2,671.83
2,671.83
TTD1
2,256.63
2,256.63
TWD1
495.16
495.16
TZS1
6.64
6.64
UAH1
544.65
544.65
UGX1
4.02
4.02
USD1
15,210.90
15,210.90
UYU1
461.08
461.08
UZS1
1.85
1.85
VEF1
0.06
0.06
VND1
0.65
0.65
VUV1
136.84
136.84
WST1
5,816.37
5,816.37
XAF1
26.84
26.84
XAG1
222,976.18
222,976.18
XAU1
18,633,729.83
18,633,729.83
XCD1
5,628.35
5,628.35
XDR1
21,279.99
21,279.99
XOF1
26.84
26.84
XPD1
16,482,705.56
16,482,705.56
XPF1
147.56
147.56
XPT1
12,817,490.07
12,817,490.07
YER1
60.75
60.75
ZAR1
1,072.69
1,072.69
ZMW1
1,258.28
1,258.28
ZWL1
47.18
47.18
Taxation Exchange Rates
31 Aug 16 - 06 Sep 16
USD 1
13,232.00
AUD 1
10,043.30
CAD 1
10,213.70
DKK 1
1,999.40
HKD 1
1,706.22
MYR 1
3,283.28
NZD 1
9,623.63
NOK 1
1,605.23
GBP 1
17,433.70
SGD 1
9,757.68
SEK 1
1,569.45
CHF 1
13,631.10
JPY 100
13,101.00
MMK 1
11.01
INR 1
197.29
KWD 1
43,920.70
PKR 1
126.23
PHP 1
285.00
SAR 1
3,528.53
LKR 1
91.12
THB 1
382.08
BND 1
9,756.53
EUR 1
14,885.50
CNY 1
1,987.61

Okusi Associates: Indonesian Business & Management Services