Mon, 30 Nov 2009
From: The Jakarta Globe
By Muhamad Al Azhari
Bambang Rachmadi has fired back at fast-food giant McDonald’s, saying the US-based corporation created “artificial” losses at their domestic joint venture while “sucking” huge earnings out.

“When [the joint venture] was operating in Indonesia from 1991 to 2008, McDonald’s sucked as much as $190 million [from it], mostly from royalties, franchise fees and interest on loans,” but he never received any profits from the venture, Bambang said in a statement last week.

He also claimed McDonald’s dual roles as franchisor and franchisee, as well as lender and borrower, were conflicts of interest.

“Currently, Bambang Rachmadi is processing a lawsuit against McDonald’s in South Jakarta District Court because McDonald’s is considered to have violated laws and have done serious manipulations that caused [him] as a local partner to suffer serious losses,” the statement said.

Bambang and McDonald’s formed PT Bina Nusa Rama in 1991. At one time it operated 97 McDonald’s outlets across the nation, and had accumulated debts of $150 million as of 2007.

In June, McDonald’s sold the assets in the 97 outlets owned by the venture and transferred its franchise rights to the Sosrodjojo family. All that remained of Bina Nusa Rama was debt.

Bambang’s legal counsel, Tri Adhyaksa, claimed in June that McDonald’s sold the assets and franchise rights for only $20 million.

After the sale, the company was left to pay $130 million in debt, which would render Bambang’s shares almost worthless.

However, McDonald’s said in a statement last week that it would honor an arrangement to determine the “fair market value” of Bambang’s 10 percent stake in Bina Nusa Rama, noting that “given the legal relationship between the parties, neither shareholder is personally responsible for any of the debts.”

Tri Adhyaksa said Bambang was seeking $105.5 million in compensation for losses.

Bambang was left with 13 independently owned McDonald’s outlets after the corporate parent’s sale of Bina Nusa Rama’s assets. McDonald’s this month demanded that he shut all his former McDonald’s outlets, which are now operating under the name ToniJack’s, claiming he had violated a contractual agreement restraining him from competing with McDonald’s outlets.

However, ToniJack’s senior management claimed on the same day that Bambang no longer had a stake in the outlets.



News Search/Filter
Transaction Rates
12 Dec 18
Buy
Sell
AED1
3,980.52
3,980.52
AFN1
192.82
192.82
ALL1
133.71
133.71
AMD1
30.10
30.10
ANG1
8,239.40
8,239.40
AOA1
47.25
47.25
ARS1
386.80
386.80
AUD1
10,546.80
10,546.80
AWG1
8,122.90
8,122.90
AZN1
8,588.07
8,588.07
BAM1
8,519.06
8,519.06
BBD1
7,310.60
7,310.60
BDT1
174.33
174.33
BGN1
8,462.51
8,462.51
BHD1
38,788.47
38,788.47
BIF1
8.13
8.13
BMD1
14,621.20
14,621.20
BND1
9,277.28
9,277.28
BOB1
2,116.42
2,116.42
BRL1
3,745.37
3,745.37
BSD1
14,621.20
14,621.20
BTC1
48,766,427
48,766,427
BTN1
203.43
203.43
BWP1
1,365.93
1,365.93
BYN1
6,893.52
6,893.52
BZD1
7,255.26
7,255.26
CAD1
10,928.40
10,928.40
CDF1
8.97
8.97
CHF1
14,721.30
14,721.30
CLF1
603,832.49
603,832.49
CLP1
21.38
21.38
CNH1
2,121.38
2,121.38
CNY1
2,119.01
2,119.01
COP1
4.55
4.55
CRC1
24.44
24.44
CUC1
14,621.20
14,621.20
CUP1
567.81
567.81
CVE1
150.15
150.15
CZK1
640.05
640.05
DJF1
82.14
82.14
DKK1
2,217.77
2,217.77
DOP1
290.84
290.84
DZD1
123.16
123.16
EGP1
816.27
816.27
ERN1
974.91
974.91
ETB1
521.32
521.32
EUR1
16,556.31
16,556.31
FJD1
6,917.17
6,917.17
FKP1
18,265.31
18,265.31
GBP1
18,265.31
18,265.31
GEL1
5,518.90
5,518.90
GGP1
18,265.31
18,265.31
GHS1
2,987.99
2,987.99
GIP1
18,265.31
18,265.31
GMD1
294.93
294.93
GNF1
1.60
1.60
GTQ1
1,890.70
1,890.70
GYD1
70.04
70.04
HKD1
1,870.54
1,870.54
HNL1
599.11
599.11
HRK1
2,240.45
2,240.45
HTG1
193.28
193.28
HUF1
51.13
51.13
IDR1
1.00
1.00
ILS1
3,897.89
3,897.89
IMP1
18,265.31
18,265.31
INR1
202.13
202.13
IQD1
12.28
12.28
IRR1
0.34
0.34
ISK1
118.05
118.05
JEP1
18,265.31
18,265.31
JMD1
114.66
114.66
JOD1
20,604.76
20,604.76
JPY1
128.96
128.96
KES1
142.71
142.71
KGS1
212.82
212.82
KHR1
3.62
3.62
KMF1
33.63
33.63
KPW1
16.24
16.24
KRW1
12.95
12.95
KWD1
48,088.14
48,088.14
KYD1
17,549.53
17,549.53
KZT1
39.46
39.46
LAK1
1.70
1.70
LBP1
9.69
9.69
LKR1
81.55
81.55
LRD1
92.49
92.49
LSL1
1,021.94
1,021.94
LYD1
10,509.14
10,509.14
MAD1
1,535.27
1,535.27
MDL1
851.31
851.31
MGA1
4.12
4.12
MKD1
269.46
269.46
MMK1
9.29
9.29
MNT1
5.95
5.95
MOP1
1,816.71
1,816.71
MRO1
40.95
40.95
MRU1
401.68
401.68
MUR1
423.48
423.48
MVR1
946.35
946.35
MWK1
19.67
19.67
MXN1
724.43
724.43
MYR1
3,494.31
3,494.31
MZN1
240.16
240.16
NAD1
1,021.94
1,021.94
NGN1
40.17
40.17
NIO1
451.01
451.01
NOK1
1,704.67
1,704.67
NPR1
127.15
127.15
NZD1
10,069.62
10,069.62
OMR1
37,978.72
37,978.72
PAB1
14,621.20
14,621.20
PEN1
4,342.39
4,342.39
PGK1
4,344.99
4,344.99
PHP1
277.19
277.19
PKR1
104.84
104.84
PLN1
3,849.37
3,849.37
PYG1
2.46
2.46
QAR1
4,015.71
4,015.71
RON1
3,554.89
3,554.89
RSD1
139.87
139.87
RUB1
220.19
220.19
RWF1
16.56
16.56
SAR1
3,897.21
3,897.21
SBD1
1,839.20
1,839.20
SCR1
1,071.93
1,071.93
SDG1
307.16
307.16
SEK1
1,609.20
1,609.20
SGD1
10,644.43
10,644.43
SHP1
18,265.31
18,265.31
SLL1
1.74
1.74
SOS1
25.20
25.20
SRD1
1,960.47
1,960.47
SSP1
112.24
112.24
STD1
0.69
0.69
STN1
673.78
673.78
SVC1
1,671.33
1,671.33
SYP1
28.39
28.39
SZL1
1,021.98
1,021.98
THB1
445.49
445.49
TJS1
1,553.41
1,553.41
TMT1
4,177.50
4,177.50
TND1
4,976.06
4,976.06
TOP1
6,379.07
6,379.07
TRY1
2,727.34
2,727.34
TTD1
2,169.82
2,169.82
TWD1
475.16
475.16
TZS1
6.32
6.32
UAH1
527.59
527.59
UGX1
3.91
3.91
USD1
14,621.20
14,621.20
UYU1
454.02
454.02
UZS1
1.76
1.76
VEF1
0.05
0.05
VND1
0.62
0.62
VUV1
131.87
131.87
WST1
5,614.16
5,614.16
XAF1
25.23
25.23
XAG1
213,074.34
213,074.34
XAU1
18,177,432.99
18,177,432.99
XCD1
5,410.14
5,410.14
XDR1
20,310.04
20,310.04
XOF1
25.23
25.23
XPD1
18,210,486.98
18,210,486.98
XPF1
138.74
138.74
XPT1
11,484,902.75
11,484,902.75
YER1
58.40
58.40
ZAR1
1,020.15
1,020.15
ZMW1
1,226.39
1,226.39
ZWL1
45.35
45.35
Taxation Exchange Rates
31 Aug 16 - 06 Sep 16
USD 1
13,232.00
AUD 1
10,043.30
CAD 1
10,213.70
DKK 1
1,999.40
HKD 1
1,706.22
MYR 1
3,283.28
NZD 1
9,623.63
NOK 1
1,605.23
GBP 1
17,433.70
SGD 1
9,757.68
SEK 1
1,569.45
CHF 1
13,631.10
JPY 100
13,101.00
MMK 1
11.01
INR 1
197.29
KWD 1
43,920.70
PKR 1
126.23
PHP 1
285.00
SAR 1
3,528.53
LKR 1
91.12
THB 1
382.08
BND 1
9,756.53
EUR 1
14,885.50
CNY 1
1,987.61

Okusi Associates: Indonesian Business & Management Services