Thu, 10 Mar 2005

Bogeyman China

Gwynne Dyer London

"Improved Chinese capabilities threaten U.S. forces in the (western Pacific) region," warned Peter Goss, new director of the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency, in testimony to Congress two weeks ago. "China continues to develop more robust...nuclear- armed missiles, as well as conventional capabilities for use in regional conflicts." Just like the United States does, in fact.

Given America's monopoly or huge technological lead in key areas like stealth bombers, aircraft carriers, long-range sensors, satellite surveillance and even infantry body armor, Goss's warning is misleading and self-serving. China cannot project a serious military force even 200 miles (km) from home, while American forces utterly dominate China's ocean frontiers, many thousands of miles (kilometers) from the United States. But the drumbeat of warnings about China's "military build-up" continues.

Just the other week U.S. Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld was worrying again about the expansion of the Chinese navy, which is finally building some amphibious landing ships half a century after Beijing's confrontation with the non-Communist regime on the island of Taiwan began. And Senator Richard Lugar, head of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, warned that if the European Union ends its embargo on arms sales to China, the U.S. would stop military technology sales to Europe.

It will come as no surprise, therefore, that the major U.S. defense review planned for this year will concentrate on the rising "threat" from China, or that this year for the first time the joint U.S.-Japanese defense policy statement named China as a "security concern", or that the Taiwan government urged the "military encirclement" of China to prevent any "foreign adventures" by Beijing. It comes as no surprise -- but it still makes no sense.

China's defense budget this year is 247.7 billion yuan: Around US$30 billion at the official exchange rate. There are those in Washington who will say that it's more like $60 billion in purchasing power, but then there used to be "experts" who annually produced hugely inflated and frightening estimates of the Soviet defense budget. Such people will always exist: to justify a big U.S. defense budget, you need a big threat.

It's true that 247.7 billion yuan buys an awful lot of warm bodies in military uniform in the low-wage Chinese economy, but it doesn't actually buy much more in the way of high-tech military systems.

It's also true that the Chinese defense budget has grown by double-digit increases for the past fourteen years: This year it's up by 12.6 percent. But that is not significantly faster than the Chinese economy as a whole is growing, and it's about what you have to spend in order to convert what used to be a glorified peasant militia into a modern military force.

It would be astonishing if China chose NOT to modernize its armed forces as the rest of the economy modernizes, and the end result is not going to be a military machine that towers above all others. If you project the current growth rates of military spending in China and the United States into the future, China's defense budget catches up with the United States about the same time that its Gross Domestic Product does, in the late 2030s or the early 2040s.

As to China's strategic intentions, the record of the past is reassuring in several respects. China has almost never been militarily expansionist beyond the traditional boundaries of the Middle Kingdom (which do include Tibet in the view of most Chinese), and its border clashes with India, the Soviet Union and Vietnam in the first decades of Communist rule generally ended with a voluntary Chinese withdrawal from the disputed territories.

The same moderation has usually applied in nuclear matters. The CIA frets that China could have a hundred nuclear missiles targeted on the United States by 2015, but that is actually evidence of China's great restraint. The first Chinese nuclear weapons test was forty years ago, and by now China could have thousands of nuclear warheads targeted on the U.S. if it wanted. (The United States DOES have thousands of nuclear warheads that can strike Chinese targets.)

The Beijing regime is obsessed with economic stability, because it fears that a severe downturn would trigger social and political upheaval. The last thing it wants is a military confrontation with its biggest trading partner, the United States. It will go on playing the nationalist card over Taiwan to curry domestic political favor, but there is no massive military build-up and no plausible threat of impending war in East Asia.

The writer is a London-based independent journalist.





News Search/Filter
Transaction Rates
16 Aug 18
Buy
Sell
AED1
3,904.98
3,904.98
AFN1
196.77
196.77
ALL1
129.39
129.39
AMD1
29.73
29.73
ANG1
7,772.77
7,772.77
AOA1
53.35
53.35
ARS1
482.14
482.14
AUD1
10,375.77
10,375.77
AWG1
7,995.37
7,995.37
AZN1
8,425.09
8,425.09
BAM1
8,299.56
8,299.56
BBD1
7,171.86
7,171.86
BDT1
169.71
169.71
BGN1
8,319.73
8,319.73
BHD1
38,038.03
38,038.03
BIF1
8.10
8.10
BMD1
14,343.72
14,343.72
BND1
9,493.49
9,493.49
BOB1
2,075.83
2,075.83
BRL1
3,675.14
3,675.14
BSD1
14,343.72
14,343.72
BTC1
90,527,612
90,527,612
BTN1
205.12
205.12
BWP1
1,324.36
1,324.36
BYN1
6,969.22
6,969.22
BZD1
7,134.69
7,134.69
CAD1
10,909.89
10,909.89
CDF1
8.81
8.81
CHF1
14,437.67
14,437.67
CLF1
613,504.02
613,504.02
CLP1
21.48
21.48
CNH1
2,065.99
2,065.99
CNY1
2,068.08
2,068.08
COP1
4.76
4.76
CRC1
25.27
25.27
CUC1
14,343.72
14,343.72
CUP1
562.49
562.49
CVE1
147.19
147.19
CZK1
631.41
631.41
DJF1
80.56
80.56
DKK1
2,182.21
2,182.21
DOP1
287.50
287.50
DZD1
120.29
120.29
EGP1
801.50
801.50
ERN1
956.45
956.45
ETB1
519.14
519.14
EUR1
16,267.66
16,267.66
FJD1
6,765.74
6,765.74
FKP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
GBP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
GEL1
5,780.22
5,780.22
GGP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
GHS1
2,943.81
2,943.81
GIP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
GMD1
297.89
297.89
GNF1
1.58
1.58
GTQ1
1,913.77
1,913.77
GYD1
68.67
68.67
HKD1
1,827.29
1,827.29
HNL1
596.66
596.66
HRK1
2,190.41
2,190.41
HTG1
212.81
212.81
HUF1
50.12
50.12
IDR1
1.00
1.00
ILS1
3,892.81
3,892.81
IMP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
INR1
204.10
204.10
IQD1
12.03
12.03
IRR1
0.33
0.33
ISK1
131.24
131.24
JEP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
JMD1
105.56
105.56
JOD1
20,216.57
20,216.57
JPY1
129.72
129.72
KES1
142.30
142.30
KGS1
210.51
210.51
KHR1
3.52
3.52
KMF1
33.06
33.06
KPW1
15.93
15.93
KRW1
12.61
12.61
KWD1
47,280.81
47,280.81
KYD1
17,207.68
17,207.68
KZT1
39.64
39.64
LAK1
1.68
1.68
LBP1
9.49
9.49
LKR1
89.54
89.54
LRD1
93.32
93.32
LSL1
1,006.22
1,006.22
LYD1
10,276.86
10,276.86
MAD1
1,497.80
1,497.80
MDL1
864.13
864.13
MGA1
4.31
4.31
MKD1
264.18
264.18
MMK1
9.47
9.47
MNT1
5.87
5.87
MOP1
1,773.66
1,773.66
MRO1
40.12
40.12
MRU1
398.99
398.99
MUR1
412.17
412.17
MVR1
927.19
927.19
MWK1
19.72
19.72
MXN1
747.55
747.55
MYR1
3,495.48
3,495.48
MZN1
245.52
245.52
NAD1
1,005.51
1,005.51
NGN1
39.74
39.74
NIO1
447.89
447.89
NOK1
1,695.20
1,695.20
NPR1
128.20
128.20
NZD1
9,405.39
9,405.39
OMR1
37,254.49
37,254.49
PAB1
14,343.72
14,343.72
PEN1
4,323.00
4,323.00
PGK1
4,328.25
4,328.25
PHP1
267.88
267.88
PKR1
116.12
116.12
PLN1
3,764.23
3,764.23
PYG1
2.49
2.49
QAR1
3,939.43
3,939.43
RON1
3,487.43
3,487.43
RSD1
137.90
137.90
RUB1
213.05
213.05
RWF1
16.33
16.33
SAR1
3,823.97
3,823.97
SBD1
1,818.16
1,818.16
SCR1
1,055.33
1,055.33
SDG1
796.69
796.69
SEK1
1,557.02
1,557.02
SGD1
10,392.95
10,392.95
SHP1
18,206.39
18,206.39
SLL1
2.19
2.19
SOS1
24.79
24.79
SRD1
1,923.26
1,923.26
SSP1
110.11
110.11
STD1
0.68
0.68
STN1
660.54
660.54
SVC1
1,638.95
1,638.95
SYP1
27.85
27.85
SZL1
984.80
984.80
THB1
430.35
430.35
TJS1
1,522.29
1,522.29
TMT1
4,098.23
4,098.23
TND1
5,154.61
5,154.61
TOP1
6,207.95
6,207.95
TRY1
2,398.64
2,398.64
TTD1
2,127.88
2,127.88
TWD1
465.08
465.08
TZS1
6.28
6.28
UAH1
522.33
522.33
UGX1
3.83
3.83
USD1
14,343.72
14,343.72
UYU1
457.87
457.87
UZS1
1.84
1.84
VEF1
0.10
0.10
VND1
0.62
0.62
VUV1
132.20
132.20
WST1
5,541.25
5,541.25
XAF1
24.79
24.79
XAG1
211,784.47
211,784.47
XAU1
17,028,223.52
17,028,223.52
XCD1
5,307.47
5,307.47
XDR1
19,983.25
19,983.25
XOF1
24.79
24.79
XPD1
14,201,707.01
14,201,707.01
XPF1
136.32
136.32
XPT1
11,291,959.19
11,291,959.19
YER1
57.28
57.28
ZAR1
984.89
984.89
ZMW1
1,405.97
1,405.97
ZWL1
44.49
44.49
Taxation Exchange Rates
31 Aug 16 - 06 Sep 16
USD 1
13,232.00
AUD 1
10,043.30
CAD 1
10,213.70
DKK 1
1,999.40
HKD 1
1,706.22
MYR 1
3,283.28
NZD 1
9,623.63
NOK 1
1,605.23
GBP 1
17,433.70
SGD 1
9,757.68
SEK 1
1,569.45
CHF 1
13,631.10
JPY 100
13,101.00
MMK 1
11.01
INR 1
197.29
KWD 1
43,920.70
PKR 1
126.23
PHP 1
285.00
SAR 1
3,528.53
LKR 1
91.12
THB 1
382.08
BND 1
9,756.53
EUR 1
14,885.50
CNY 1
1,987.61

Okusi Associates: Indonesian Business & Management Services