Sun, 27 Dec 2009
From: The Jakarta Post
By Mark A. Nelson, Singapore
As President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono works to improve the investment climate in Indonesia, regulatory surprises have slowed his progress, reinforcing the impression that Indonesia is an unpredictable place to do business.

Twice this year Indonesian legislation has caught the market unprepared, forcing market participants to grapple with an unexpected regulatory development.

Most recently, Indonesian tax authorities issued a regulation taking effect on Jan. 1 that increases withholding tax on interest and dividend payments, leaving US dollar bondholders and investors scrambling to understand its implications.

Earlier in the year, a law requiring all contracts with Indonesian parties to be in the Indonesian language disrupted the market as deal teams were required to prepare Indonesian language documents for cross-border deals previously documented only in English.

Both the tax regulation and the language law caught the business community unaware, engendering uncertainty and confusion. Fortunately, this kind of surprise is easy to avoid and there is a terrific example of how to do it better right at home in Indonesia.

Bapepam LK, the Indonesian capital markets and financial institutions supervisory agency, shows the way. Before enacting a new regulation, Bapepam first posts it in draft on its excellent website. This approach gives advance notice of pending legal changes, enabling market participants to adjust.

Bapepam also seeks comment on the draft regulation, minimizing the risk of obvious inconsistencies or unintended consequences. The Bapepam rule-making approach increases the predictability that business loves and ought to be replicated throughout the Indonesian bureaucracy.

Not having the benefit of the Bapepam approach, the tax regulation - Regulation 62 on Prevention of Tax Treaty Abuse - caught business unaware. Regulation 62 denies the use of reduced withholding tax rates under Indonesia's tax treaties, invalidating structures using offshore single purpose vehicles (SPVs) that reduce or eliminate withholding tax on interest payments for Indonesian bond issuers as well as dividends and capital gains paid to investors in Indonesian private companies. The resulting tax increases are significant, increasing withholding taxes from 10 percent or less under the tax treaties to 20 percent when the treaties don't apply.

But the substance of Regulation 62 is not the problem. The regulation is largely aligned with international practice in attempting to disallow purely tax-driven structures. No, the reason Regulation 62 jolted the market was because of the way it was issued and the way it enters into force.

First, it was issued out of the blue, with no prior notice or discussion.

Second, the seven week grace period between its Nov. 5 issue date and its Jan. 1 effective dates is too short given the substantive and procedural changes Regulation 62 and a sister tax regulation make.

Third, the regulation is retroactive in application: From Jan.1 not only future structures will be caught in the tax net but existing structures will be caught as well.

For evidence of how unprepared the business community was for Regulation 62, look no further than the issuance of bonds in October by state-owned Indonesian utility Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PLN). The PLN bond uses an SPV borrowing affiliate that likely will not give the intended tax benefits once Regulation 62 takes effect. PLN doubtless would have reconsidered the use of the SPV had it been aware of the impending issuance of Regulation 62. Similarly, dozens of existing US dollar bonds and equity holding company structures may have to be restructured as a result of Regulation 62.

Had Regulation 62 been introduced Bapepam-style, there would have been no surprise and the seven week grace period probably would have been adequate. It is also possible that comments of market participants would have convinced Indonesian tax authorities to grandfather existing SPV structures.

The other regulatory surprise arrived quietly on July 9 in the form of omnibus Law 24 of 2009 re "National Flag, Language and State Symbol and National Anthem". Buried in the law is a provision requiring all contracts with Indonesian parties to be in the Indonesian language.

Although the ambiguous langue of Law 24 leaves room for doubt regarding the intentions of the draftsmen, mainstream legal practice overnight has become that all contracts with Indonesian parties in cross-border transactions need to have an Indonesian version as well as an English version. Failure to do so may mean un-enforceable documents.

Again, the substance of Law 24 was not the problem - a case can be made that contracts with Indonesian parties should be in the Indonesian language, increasing the likelihood that the parties fully understand what they are signing. Many countries have such a law.

No, the problem is the way the law was announced, with no advance notice and taking immediate effect.

Law 24 also caught the market totally unaware. In the weeks following its issuance and effective date of July 9, several big Indonesian deals were documented using only English language documents. Why was this risk taken, given that non-Indonesian language documents may not be enforceable under Law 24? Because none of the parties involved was even aware that Law 24 had entered into force.

Both Regulation 62 and Law 24 would have caused less market indigestion had people known they were being proposed and had there been an opportunity to comment on the drafts. The Bapepam approach of posting draft regulations for comment is best practice for rule-making and would have minimized the disruption.

Fortunately, the Bapepam approach can be readily replicated across agencies in Indonesia. Doing so would minimize disruptive regulatory surprises such as Regulation 62 and Law 24 and make Indonesia a more predictable place to do business.

The writer is an American lawyer, a partner in the Singapore office of Latham & Watkins LLP.


Sun, 27 Dec 2009
From: JakChat
Comment by Marmalade
"scrambling to understand its implications."
WTF?




News Search/Filter
Transaction Rates
25 May 18
Buy
Sell
AED1
3,850.96
3,850.96
AFN1
196.95
196.95
ALL1
130.92
130.92
AMD1
29.32
29.32
ANG1
7,879.79
7,879.79
AOA1
60.26
60.26
ARS1
575.53
575.53
AUD1
10,708.97
10,708.97
AWG1
7,913.45
7,913.45
AZN1
8,308.55
8,308.55
BAM1
8,476.02
8,476.02
BBD1
7,072.65
7,072.65
BDT1
167.37
167.37
BGN1
8,477.62
8,477.62
BHD1
37,460.09
37,460.09
BIF1
7.99
7.99
BMD1
14,145.30
14,145.30
BND1
10,512.24
10,512.24
BOB1
2,046.94
2,046.94
BRL1
3,876.07
3,876.07
BSD1
14,145.30
14,145.30
BTC1
105,234,969
105,234,969
BTN1
207.19
207.19
BWP1
1,427.85
1,427.85
BYN1
7,086.24
7,086.24
BZD1
7,036.94
7,036.94
CAD1
10,976.83
10,976.83
CDF1
8.76
8.76
CHF1
14,268.93
14,268.93
CLF1
617,159.97
617,159.97
CLP1
22.56
22.56
CNH1
2,218.34
2,218.34
CNY1
2,217.96
2,217.96
COP1
4.87
4.87
CRC1
25.01
25.01
CUC1
14,145.30
14,145.30
CUP1
554.71
554.71
CVE1
149.98
149.98
CZK1
642.82
642.82
DJF1
79.49
79.49
DKK1
2,225.99
2,225.99
DOP1
285.56
285.56
DZD1
121.59
121.59
EGP1
789.46
789.46
ERN1
941.13
941.13
ETB1
513.99
513.99
EUR1
16,581.27
16,581.27
FJD1
6,857.51
6,857.51
FKP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
GBP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
GEL1
5,726.61
5,726.61
GGP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
GHS1
3,041.94
3,041.94
GIP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
GMD1
299.95
299.95
GNF1
1.57
1.57
GTQ1
1,896.70
1,896.70
GYD1
67.71
67.71
HKD1
1,802.47
1,802.47
HNL1
592.76
592.76
HRK1
2,242.51
2,242.51
HTG1
219.77
219.77
HUF1
51.92
51.92
IDR1
1.00
1.00
ILS1
3,966.63
3,966.63
IMP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
INR1
207.19
207.19
IQD1
11.88
11.88
IRR1
0.33
0.33
ISK1
133.90
133.90
JEP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
JMD1
112.08
112.08
JOD1
19,936.92
19,936.92
JPY1
129.39
129.39
KES1
139.92
139.92
KGS1
207.06
207.06
KHR1
3.47
3.47
KMF1
33.69
33.69
KPW1
15.71
15.71
KRW1
13.09
13.09
KWD1
46,848.22
46,848.22
KYD1
16,973.01
16,973.01
KZT1
43.36
43.36
LAK1
1.69
1.69
LBP1
9.33
9.33
LKR1
89.47
89.47
LRD1
103.18
103.18
LSL1
1,119.33
1,119.33
LYD1
10,394.52
10,394.52
MAD1
1,493.28
1,493.28
MDL1
841.35
841.35
MGA1
4.32
4.32
MKD1
269.18
269.18
MMK1
10.44
10.44
MNT1
5.87
5.87
MOP1
1,749.93
1,749.93
MRO1
39.73
39.73
MRU1
396.11
396.11
MUR1
408.27
408.27
MVR1
912.02
912.02
MWK1
19.65
19.65
MXN1
722.40
722.40
MYR1
3,554.57
3,554.57
MZN1
234.11
234.11
NAD1
1,116.88
1,116.88
NGN1
39.31
39.31
NIO1
450.43
450.43
NOK1
1,746.35
1,746.35
NPR1
129.48
129.48
NZD1
9,801.28
9,801.28
OMR1
36,743.25
36,743.25
PAB1
14,145.30
14,145.30
PEN1
4,327.14
4,327.14
PGK1
4,332.66
4,332.66
PHP1
269.32
269.32
PKR1
122.28
122.28
PLN1
3,847.33
3,847.33
PYG1
2.48
2.48
QAR1
3,885.00
3,885.00
RON1
3,581.60
3,581.60
RSD1
140.29
140.29
RUB1
229.77
229.77
RWF1
16.32
16.32
SAR1
3,771.88
3,771.88
SBD1
1,790.84
1,790.84
SCR1
1,051.30
1,051.30
SDG1
783.50
783.50
SEK1
1,613.75
1,613.75
SGD1
10,554.57
10,554.57
SHP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
SLL1
1.80
1.80
SOS1
24.56
24.56
SRD1
1,894.12
1,894.12
SSP1
108.59
108.59
STD1
0.67
0.67
STN1
676.16
676.16
SVC1
1,616.54
1,616.54
SYP1
27.46
27.46
SZL1
1,119.88
1,119.88
THB1
441.84
441.84
TJS1
1,574.14
1,574.14
TMT1
4,030.02
4,030.02
TND1
5,576.26
5,576.26
TOP1
6,206.88
6,206.88
TRY1
2,973.29
2,973.29
TTD1
2,098.57
2,098.57
TWD1
472.64
472.64
TZS1
6.19
6.19
UAH1
541.50
541.50
UGX1
3.76
3.76
USD1
14,145.30
14,145.30
UYU1
452.88
452.88
UZS1
1.76
1.76
VEF1
0.17
0.17
VND1
0.62
0.62
VUV1
132.14
132.14
WST1
5,503.79
5,503.79
XAF1
25.27
25.27
XAG1
235,660.45
235,660.45
XAU1
18,451,763.69
18,451,763.69
XCD1
5,234.05
5,234.05
XDR1
20,072.17
20,072.17
XOF1
25.27
25.27
XPD1
13,826,603.35
13,826,603.35
XPF1
138.95
138.95
XPT1
12,891,716.09
12,891,716.09
YER1
56.50
56.50
ZAR1
1,138.22
1,138.22
ZMW1
1,377.87
1,377.87
ZWL1
43.88
43.88
Taxation Exchange Rates
31 Aug 16 - 06 Sep 16
USD 1
13,232.00
AUD 1
10,043.30
CAD 1
10,213.70
DKK 1
1,999.40
HKD 1
1,706.22
MYR 1
3,283.28
NZD 1
9,623.63
NOK 1
1,605.23
GBP 1
17,433.70
SGD 1
9,757.68
SEK 1
1,569.45
CHF 1
13,631.10
JPY 100
13,101.00
MMK 1
11.01
INR 1
197.29
KWD 1
43,920.70
PKR 1
126.23
PHP 1
285.00
SAR 1
3,528.53
LKR 1
91.12
THB 1
382.08
BND 1
9,756.53
EUR 1
14,885.50
CNY 1
1,987.61

Okusi Associates: Indonesian Business & Management Services