Wed, 01 Nov 2006
From: The Jakarta Post
By Monday, October 30th, 2006
Neither the Indonesian government nor ExxonMobil will gain from a protracted spat over the status of the production-sharing contract for the development of the Natuna D-Alpha natural gas block in the East Natuna Sea.

Instead, both parties will lose if this feud escalates into a legal battle or arbitration process, which could drag on for years.

Another bout of dispute between the government and ExxonMobil, only a few months after the resolution of the five-year ExxonMobil-Pertamina quarrel over the Cepu oil block in East Java, would only hurt both sides.

The American oil giant, which claims to have spent US$350 million on exploring the D-Alpha block, would not only lose its investment but could also encounter a stronger wave of nationalistic sentiment against its operations in Indonesia.

On the other hand, new oil and gas investors could be scared off by what they might consider to be the heavy-handed manner and capricious attitude the government has toward its contracts.

One might initially be confused as to how BP Migas - representing the government - and ExxonMobil could have come up with so widely different interpretations of such an important contract involving up to $45 billion in investment commitment.

ExxonMobil owns 76 percent of the gas concession with state oil and gas company Pertamina holding the remaining 24 percent.
BP Migas chairman Kardaya Warnika and Energy and Mineral Resources Minister Purnomo Yusgiantoro confirmed on Oct. 11 the government had terminated the ExxonMobil-Pertamina contract and would later decide whether to retender the concession for fresh bids because the contractor failed to fulfill the requirements for the contract’s extension.

But ExxonMobil immediately denied the government statement, asserting that legally, the firm could continue development preparation until January 2009. The giant oil company claims the contract, which was revised in 1995, is extendible twice, each time for two years, after its maturity in 2005. ExxonMobil’s general manager for Indonesia Peter Coleman even convincingly said on Oct.12 that he had just met with Warnika and the BP Migas chief did not mention anything about contract renegotiations.

But setting this spat against the demand for contract revision Vice President Jusuf Kalla made earlier at his meeting with ExxonMobil senior executives in Washington late last September, one could easily get the impression the government was bent on
having the contract amended because it gives the contractor a 100 percent output split, instead of the 35 to 40 percent other gas concessionaires in the country usually get.

When the contract was revised in 1995 neither the Soeharto administration nor ExxonMobil had anticipated that natural gas prices would skyrocket to record highs, along with oil prices, which rose from $15 in 1995 to about $65/barrel now. Hence, no one at the mineral resources ministry then thought about the need to attach a price-escalation clause to the production split as the government and ExxonMobil did early this year for the production-sharing contract for the Cepu oil block in East Java.

The 100 percent production split for the ExxonMobil-Pertamina contract was then considered fair and necessary to encourage the contractor to invest huge sums in developing the gas field. Unlike other gas blocks, the development of the Natuna D-Alpha field is seen as much more difficult, extremely costly and complex due to the low quality and high carbon-dioxide content of its gas.

ExxonMobil has estimated the Natuna D-Alpha block contains around 46 trillion cubic feet of commercially recoverable gas, but due to the 70 percent carbon dioxide content of its gas the Natuna D-Alpha development could cost between $35-40 billion. The American oil giant claims that even under the current production split, the Indonesian government would earn minimally $13 billion in taxes, net-gas revenues and production bonus for each billion cubic feet of gas sold from the block.

Since both parties have big stakes in the contract, it is clear they are doing their best to resolve their differences.
ExxonMobil, which has big operations and will stay in the country for a long time, would be well-advised to review its 100 percent production split against the current natural gas market conditions. Stubbornly holding to the 1995 contractual terms will only heighten narrow-minded nationalistic sentiment against its presence in the country.

But the government should be reasonable in its demand for the contract’s revision, otherwise it will damage its credibility and earn itself a bad reputation for not honoring the sanctity
of contract.

The government also should draw whatever lessons it can from this spat by wising up to the importance of going through contracts with a fine-tooth comb and marking any articles, paragraphs or words that do not fit.




News Search/Filter
Transaction Rates
23 Jun 18
Buy
Sell
AED1
3,824.31
3,824.31
AFN1
196.35
196.35
ALL1
129.23
129.23
AMD1
29.14
29.14
ANG1
7,740.29
7,740.29
AOA1
57.11
57.11
ARS1
520.33
520.33
AUD1
10,454.06
10,454.06
AWG1
7,852.06
7,852.06
AZN1
8,251.03
8,251.03
BAM1
8,363.06
8,363.06
BBD1
7,023.69
7,023.69
BDT1
166.26
166.26
BGN1
8,373.47
8,373.47
BHD1
37,055.64
37,055.64
BIF1
7.86
7.86
BMD1
14,047.38
14,047.38
BND1
9,298.32
9,298.32
BOB1
2,033.15
2,033.15
BRL1
3,710.25
3,710.25
BSD1
14,047.38
14,047.38
BTC1
86,176,192
86,176,192
BTN1
207.23
207.23
BWP1
1,361.29
1,361.29
BYN1
7,044.75
7,044.75
BZD1
6,989.60
6,989.60
CAD1
10,580.49
10,580.49
CDF1
8.69
8.69
CHF1
14,212.32
14,212.32
CLF1
603,669.49
603,669.49
CLP1
22.00
22.00
CNH1
2,158.09
2,158.09
CNY1
2,159.40
2,159.40
COP1
4.81
4.81
CRC1
24.77
24.77
CUC1
14,047.38
14,047.38
CUP1
550.87
550.87
CVE1
147.61
147.61
CZK1
635.21
635.21
DJF1
78.89
78.89
DKK1
2,197.09
2,197.09
DOP1
284.01
284.01
DZD1
119.75
119.75
EGP1
786.94
786.94
ERN1
929.75
929.75
ETB1
509.14
509.14
EUR1
16,388.38
16,388.38
FJD1
6,692.42
6,692.42
FKP1
18,632.71
18,632.71
GBP1
18,632.71
18,632.71
GEL1
5,719.98
5,719.98
GGP1
18,632.71
18,632.71
GHS1
2,970.60
2,970.60
GIP1
18,632.71
18,632.71
GMD1
297.14
297.14
GNF1
1.55
1.55
GTQ1
1,874.45
1,874.45
GYD1
67.17
67.17
HKD1
1,789.96
1,789.96
HNL1
587.15
587.15
HRK1
2,219.07
2,219.07
HTG1
211.00
211.00
HUF1
50.43
50.43
IDR1
1.00
1.00
ILS1
3,895.92
3,895.92
IMP1
18,632.71
18,632.71
INR1
206.99
206.99
IQD1
11.81
11.81
IRR1
0.33
0.33
ISK1
129.61
129.61
JEP1
18,632.71
18,632.71
JMD1
107.01
107.01
JOD1
19,776.53
19,776.53
JPY1
127.74
127.74
KES1
139.19
139.19
KGS1
205.80
205.80
KHR1
3.45
3.45
KMF1
33.26
33.26
KPW1
15.60
15.60
KRW1
12.63
12.63
KWD1
46,431.20
46,431.20
KYD1
16,857.64
16,857.64
KZT1
41.31
41.31
LAK1
1.66
1.66
LBP1
9.29
9.29
LKR1
88.35
88.35
LRD1
95.60
95.60
LSL1
1,044.80
1,044.80
LYD1
10,367.07
10,367.07
MAD1
1,477.11
1,477.11
MDL1
827.66
827.66
MGA1
4.22
4.22
MKD1
265.57
265.57
MMK1
10.12
10.12
MNT1
5.76
5.76
MOP1
1,738.48
1,738.48
MRO1
39.45
39.45
MRU1
392.93
392.93
MUR1
402.47
402.47
MVR1
912.16
912.16
MWK1
18.60
18.60
MXN1
702.15
702.15
MYR1
3,510.08
3,510.08
MZN1
235.69
235.69
NAD1
1,045.58
1,045.58
NGN1
39.02
39.02
NIO1
442.99
442.99
NOK1
1,735.48
1,735.48
NPR1
129.55
129.55
NZD1
9,702.57
9,702.57
OMR1
36,484.26
36,484.26
PAB1
14,047.38
14,047.38
PEN1
4,298.46
4,298.46
PGK1
4,284.70
4,284.70
PHP1
264.02
264.02
PKR1
115.52
115.52
PLN1
3,788.72
3,788.72
PYG1
2.46
2.46
QAR1
3,858.00
3,858.00
RON1
3,513.87
3,513.87
RSD1
138.67
138.67
RUB1
223.06
223.06
RWF1
16.32
16.32
SAR1
3,745.82
3,745.82
SBD1
1,774.99
1,774.99
SCR1
1,037.38
1,037.38
SDG1
779.97
779.97
SEK1
1,586.46
1,586.46
SGD1
10,341.88
10,341.88
SHP1
18,632.71
18,632.71
SLL1
2.22
2.22
SOS1
24.17
24.17
SRD1
1,881.01
1,881.01
SSP1
107.83
107.83
STD1
0.66
0.66
STN1
664.49
664.49
SVC1
1,605.51
1,605.51
SYP1
27.27
27.27
SZL1
1,044.80
1,044.80
THB1
426.93
426.93
TJS1
1,542.66
1,542.66
TMT1
4,013.55
4,013.55
TND1
5,410.33
5,410.33
TOP1
6,124.24
6,124.24
TRY1
3,003.52
3,003.52
TTD1
2,084.44
2,084.44
TWD1
463.41
463.41
TZS1
6.17
6.17
UAH1
535.49
535.49
UGX1
3.63
3.63
USD1
14,047.38
14,047.38
UYU1
443.36
443.36
UZS1
1.78
1.78
VEF1
0.17
0.17
VND1
0.61
0.61
VUV1
129.28
129.28
WST1
5,440.99
5,440.99
XAF1
24.98
24.98
XAG1
231,119.56
231,119.56
XAU1
17,832,066.98
17,832,066.98
XCD1
5,197.82
5,197.82
XDR1
19,827.69
19,827.69
XOF1
24.98
24.98
XPD1
13,481,179.54
13,481,179.54
XPF1
137.33
137.33
XPT1
12,333,414.48
12,333,414.48
YER1
56.12
56.12
ZAR1
1,045.74
1,045.74
ZMW1
1,394.42
1,394.42
ZWL1
43.57
43.57
Taxation Exchange Rates
31 Aug 16 - 06 Sep 16
USD 1
13,232.00
AUD 1
10,043.30
CAD 1
10,213.70
DKK 1
1,999.40
HKD 1
1,706.22
MYR 1
3,283.28
NZD 1
9,623.63
NOK 1
1,605.23
GBP 1
17,433.70
SGD 1
9,757.68
SEK 1
1,569.45
CHF 1
13,631.10
JPY 100
13,101.00
MMK 1
11.01
INR 1
197.29
KWD 1
43,920.70
PKR 1
126.23
PHP 1
285.00
SAR 1
3,528.53
LKR 1
91.12
THB 1
382.08
BND 1
9,756.53
EUR 1
14,885.50
CNY 1
1,987.61

Okusi Associates: Indonesian Business & Management Services