Thu, 29 Jul 2010
It is mind-boggling to learn of the complete ignorance on the part of the Home Ministry regarding the thousands of regional bylaws on taxes and user charges/retributions throughout the country that are greatly inimical to investments and regional trade.

As of last year, the Finance Ministry recommended the Home Ministry revoke more than 4,885 regional bylaws because they contravene the national laws, but only around 1,835 of the total were annulled.

Hence, there are still more than 3,000 regional bylaws, which remain in force even though they contradict national laws and, yet more damaging, hurt private investment and regional trade.

Yet more flabbergasting is that the Home Ministry has remained mired in bureaucratic inertia even though its leader since last October, Gamawan Fauzi, had previously been the regent of Solok, West Sumatra, and then the governor of that province before he was appointed to the Cabinet.

The many years Fauzi had spent in governing a regency and a province should have taught him to realize how crucial investment and trade for regional economies is. He should have been fully aware that it is private investment, not the public administration, that generates jobs. It is jobs that generate wages and it is wages that generate purchasing power for the people to buy goods and services.

Hence, Fauzi must have realized how urgent has it been for his ministry to implement the recommendation of the Finance Ministry because it is the latter that is technically competent to analyze whether regional bylaws on taxes and user charges/fees contravene the national laws or not.

The big question is why the Home Ministry has not shown any sense of urgency to act on the Finance Ministry’s recommendation. It instead let the business-unfriendly regulations hurt business operations.

Most of the regional bylaws on taxes and user charges do not make any sense in that there is no reason whatsoever for regional administrations to charge user fees or collect local taxes from the public services stipulated in the bylaws. They are simply misguided regulations issued by narrow-minded administrations to raise revenue without due regard to their damaging impact on the local economy as a whole. These bylaws have unnecessarily increased the costs of doing business.

Regional administrations cannot claim lack of knowledge or misinterpretation of national laws as the reason for the promulgation of the faulty bylaws. The misguided bylaws are simply the products of a rent-seeking mentality.

The new 2009 Regional Taxes and User Fees Law approved by the government last year stipulates clear-cut provisions on the division of taxing power between the national, provincial and regency and municipal governments. The new law also stipulates only 16 types of taxes and user fees regional administrations are authorized to impose. Eleven are authorized for regency and city governments where local autonomy is anchored, with the other five mandated for provincial administrations.

It is therefore most urgent and imperative for the Home Ministry to act soon on the Finance Ministry’s recommendations for the annulment of the more than 3,000 bylaws on regional taxes and user charges that contravene the national laws and are inimical to businesses.

The concerted efforts undertaken by the central government to woo new investment would be rendered less effective if regional administrations remain hostile to businesses because most resource-based investment projects are located outside Jakarta.



News Search/Filter
Transaction Rates
19 Sep 18
Buy
Sell
AED1
3,923.78
3,923.78
AFN1
191.22
191.22
ALL1
132.86
132.86
AMD1
29.75
29.75
ANG1
7,814.78
7,814.78
AOA1
50.43
50.43
ARS1
362.50
362.50
AUD1
10,412.55
10,412.55
AWG1
8,000.41
8,000.41
AZN1
8,465.65
8,465.65
BAM1
8,612.62
8,612.62
BBD1
7,206.38
7,206.38
BDT1
171.79
171.79
BGN1
8,606.69
8,606.69
BHD1
38,220.14
38,220.14
BIF1
8.12
8.12
BMD1
14,412.77
14,412.77
BND1
9,539.47
9,539.47
BOB1
2,086.56
2,086.56
BRL1
3,464.53
3,464.53
BSD1
14,412.77
14,412.77
BTC1
91,353,058
91,353,058
BTN1
198.40
198.40
BWP1
1,321.97
1,321.97
BYN1
6,813.93
6,813.93
BZD1
7,173.18
7,173.18
CAD1
11,109.98
11,109.98
CDF1
8.78
8.78
CHF1
14,954.11
14,954.11
CLF1
616,457.50
616,457.50
CLP1
21.07
21.07
CNH1
2,100.74
2,100.74
CNY1
2,100.31
2,100.31
COP1
4.77
4.77
CRC1
24.94
24.94
CUC1
14,412.77
14,412.77
CUP1
565.20
565.20
CVE1
152.55
152.55
CZK1
661.85
661.85
DJF1
80.72
80.72
DKK1
2,256.03
2,256.03
DOP1
288.44
288.44
DZD1
122.13
122.13
EGP1
804.66
804.66
ERN1
961.03
961.03
ETB1
520.44
520.44
EUR1
16,829.80
16,829.80
FJD1
6,798.31
6,798.31
FKP1
18,977.31
18,977.31
GBP1
18,977.31
18,977.31
GEL1
5,890.00
5,890.00
GGP1
18,977.31
18,977.31
GHS1
3,021.86
3,021.86
GIP1
18,977.31
18,977.31
GMD1
296.25
296.25
GNF1
1.59
1.59
GTQ1
1,882.87
1,882.87
GYD1
68.96
68.96
HKD1
1,837.43
1,837.43
HNL1
600.05
600.05
HRK1
2,265.55
2,265.55
HTG1
207.72
207.72
HUF1
51.96
51.96
IDR1
1.00
1.00
ILS1
4,014.35
4,014.35
IMP1
18,977.31
18,977.31
INR1
197.83
197.83
IQD1
12.09
12.09
IRR1
0.33
0.33
ISK1
131.46
131.46
JEP1
18,977.31
18,977.31
JMD1
106.05
106.05
JOD1
20,313.90
20,313.90
JPY1
128.36
128.36
KES1
142.84
142.84
KGS1
211.52
211.52
KHR1
3.51
3.51
KMF1
34.21
34.21
KPW1
16.01
16.01
KRW1
12.84
12.84
KWD1
47,578.38
47,578.38
KYD1
17,301.62
17,301.62
KZT1
39.27
39.27
LAK1
1.69
1.69
LBP1
9.52
9.52
LKR1
87.17
87.17
LRD1
90.13
90.13
LSL1
968.25
968.25
LYD1
10,411.78
10,411.78
MAD1
1,534.80
1,534.80
MDL1
856.69
856.69
MGA1
4.22
4.22
MKD1
273.36
273.36
MMK1
9.23
9.23
MNT1
5.90
5.90
MOP1
1,784.55
1,784.55
MRO1
40.31
40.31
MRU1
402.59
402.59
MUR1
419.58
419.58
MVR1
935.89
935.89
MWK1
19.81
19.81
MXN1
766.51
766.51
MYR1
3,479.24
3,479.24
MZN1
237.59
237.59
NAD1
968.25
968.25
NGN1
39.75
39.75
NIO1
449.51
449.51
NOK1
1,767.47
1,767.47
NPR1
124.00
124.00
NZD1
9,493.62
9,493.62
OMR1
37,430.33
37,430.33
PAB1
14,412.77
14,412.77
PEN1
4,360.47
4,360.47
PGK1
4,337.72
4,337.72
PHP1
266.56
266.56
PKR1
116.88
116.88
PLN1
3,924.82
3,924.82
PYG1
2.46
2.46
QAR1
3,958.44
3,958.44
RON1
3,623.13
3,623.13
RSD1
142.27
142.27
RUB1
213.93
213.93
RWF1
16.47
16.47
SAR1
3,843.04
3,843.04
SBD1
1,826.92
1,826.92
SCR1
1,059.40
1,059.40
SDG1
800.99
800.99
SEK1
1,618.75
1,618.75
SGD1
10,520.60
10,520.60
SHP1
18,977.31
18,977.31
SLL1
1.71
1.71
SOS1
24.93
24.93
SRD1
1,932.52
1,932.52
SSP1
110.64
110.64
STD1
0.68
0.68
STN1
696.26
696.26
SVC1
1,647.71
1,647.71
SYP1
27.98
27.98
SZL1
967.73
967.73
THB1
442.65
442.65
TJS1
1,529.79
1,529.79
TMT1
4,106.22
4,106.22
TND1
5,187.43
5,187.43
TOP1
6,237.84
6,237.84
TRY1
2,252.29
2,252.29
TTD1
2,139.16
2,139.16
TWD1
468.97
468.97
TZS1
6.31
6.31
UAH1
512.08
512.08
UGX1
3.77
3.77
USD1
14,412.77
14,412.77
UYU1
434.44
434.44
UZS1
1.79
1.79
VEF1
0.05
0.05
VND1
0.62
0.62
VUV1
132.83
132.83
WST1
5,567.93
5,567.93
XAF1
25.65
25.65
XAG1
204,300.46
204,300.46
XAU1
17,289,799.16
17,289,799.16
XCD1
5,333.02
5,333.02
XDR1
20,209.56
20,209.56
XOF1
25.65
25.65
XPD1
14,605,570.10
14,605,570.10
XPF1
141.03
141.03
XPT1
11,746,354.18
11,746,354.18
YER1
57.58
57.58
ZAR1
968.98
968.98
ZMW1
1,325.82
1,325.82
ZWL1
44.71
44.71
Taxation Exchange Rates
31 Aug 16 - 06 Sep 16
USD 1
13,232.00
AUD 1
10,043.30
CAD 1
10,213.70
DKK 1
1,999.40
HKD 1
1,706.22
MYR 1
3,283.28
NZD 1
9,623.63
NOK 1
1,605.23
GBP 1
17,433.70
SGD 1
9,757.68
SEK 1
1,569.45
CHF 1
13,631.10
JPY 100
13,101.00
MMK 1
11.01
INR 1
197.29
KWD 1
43,920.70
PKR 1
126.23
PHP 1
285.00
SAR 1
3,528.53
LKR 1
91.12
THB 1
382.08
BND 1
9,756.53
EUR 1
14,885.50
CNY 1
1,987.61

Okusi Associates: Indonesian Business & Management Services