Thu, 23 Nov 2006
From: The Jakarta Post
By Zatni Arbi, Contributor, Jakarta
When President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono attended the APEC Summit Meeting in Chile in late 2004, Craig Mundie, currently Microsoft's chief research and strategy officer, happened to be the person to whom it fell to introduce the President to the forum.

Since then, the two of them have bumped into each other a couple of times, including during President Yudhoyono's visit to Redmond in the U.S. state of Washington in May 2005, and at the subsequent APEC leadership meeting in Busan, South Korea, in November 2005.

Last week, Mundie, who works closely with Bill Gates and is responsible for working with policymakers around the world, came to Jakarta to meet with Yudhoyono while on his way to the APEC Meeting in Hanoi.

Along with three other media publications, The Jakarta Post was given an opportunity to talk with Mundie the evening before he was scheduled to meet the President.

During the discussion, some standard questions were raised, such as whether intellectual property rights (IPR) were one of the issues he would talk to the President about.

It should have been a hot issue, as Indonesia is still ranked third in software piracy after Vietnam and Zimbabwe, according to 2005 data. Mundie was noncommittal, however.

"We are here to discuss what Microsoft can do to help Indonesia grow its ICT industry, especially the local software development sector," he said.

But of course, he explained, IPR protection and law enforcement provided the foundation for an environment in which the software industry could flourish.

In addition, there was no limit to best practices from around the world that Indonesia could study and adopt. Mundie provided the example of how China had helped stimulate its local software industry.

In China, he said, the government budget for buying new computers for the last few years had been broken down into hardware and software allocations. This gave assurances to local software developers that the fruits of their labor would be recognized as having market value, thus encouraging them to produce more. It made sense as software development could never survive as a labor of love alone.

Protection of IPR remains Indonesia's Achilles heel. Even today, a lot of pirated software is still used in government offices. This has serious consequences for law enforcement.

The running joke at the moment is that IPR raids are carried out here by law enforcement agencies that themselves use illegal software in their offices.

Mundie stressed that he was "more interested in future issues that technologies could represent as opportunities and challenges."

It was easy to tell developing countries to look at India and China, and then try to replicate their success stories, but perhaps Indonesia should take a more cautious approach. Indonesia differed in a lot of respects from India and China.

India had experienced rapid growth in its information and communications technology (ICT) industry due to the influence of the Indian diaspora, the members of which had accumulated tremendous financial wealth and entrepreneurial experience in Silicon Valley, and then decided to return home and work on building an Indian IT industry.

Meanwhile, China had been growing thanks to massive amounts of foreign direct investment.

Indonesia, on the other hand, did not have large numbers of successful overseas-based entrepreneurs who could return to build up the country's economy. Nor had it succeeded in attracting large inflows of foreign direct investment.

Mundie said that Indonesia had to find its own strengths and identify the niche segments in which it could set itself apart.

Having worked with the Russian government quite extensively, Mundie mentioned how the need to find special strategies had been recognized there.

The Russians were very good in fields such as advanced mathematics, state-owned enterprises, aerospace, nuclear and other sophisticated engineering. They could differentiate themselves from the Indians and Chinese by focusing more on these selective fields as they harnessed their engineering talents and put them to use in software development houses.

"Unfortunately, this is my first visit here, and I still have a lot to learn about Indonesia before recommending what selected fields Indonesia should focus on".

He warned, however, that competing on the basis of low cost alone would be a bad strategy.

When asked whether a top-down approach was a prerequisite for a country's ICT development, Mundie said that in some countries, like India, for example, the driving force was not the government. In other countries, especially Malaysia, it was clear that visionary leaders had taken the driver's seat.

In Indonesia, we have had a series of government initiatives and programs, but the fact remains that we are still far behind in our ICT development. So, which is the better approach?

In responding, Mundie once again gave the example of India. In that country, the government helped the IT industry grow by not standing in its way. Large companies, such as Infosys and Wipro, were allowed to set up their own internal universities. These were privately run and funded.

They invited world-class teaching staff to educate local people, who would then find work with the companies. The government leadership could help by serving as a catalyst for the industry's growth.

President Yudhoyono recently inaugurated the National ICT Council, which involves a number of ministries. It is a move we all should support. Mundie has reportedly been asked to advise the council.

While Indonesia certainly has a lot of capable and competent people who can contribute to the advancement of its ICT ecosystem, there is still so much global experience that we can tap into from outsiders like Craig Mundie.



News Search/Filter
Transaction Rates
25 May 18
Buy
Sell
AED1
3,850.96
3,850.96
AFN1
196.95
196.95
ALL1
130.92
130.92
AMD1
29.32
29.32
ANG1
7,879.79
7,879.79
AOA1
60.26
60.26
ARS1
575.53
575.53
AUD1
10,708.97
10,708.97
AWG1
7,913.45
7,913.45
AZN1
8,308.55
8,308.55
BAM1
8,476.02
8,476.02
BBD1
7,072.65
7,072.65
BDT1
167.37
167.37
BGN1
8,477.62
8,477.62
BHD1
37,460.09
37,460.09
BIF1
7.99
7.99
BMD1
14,145.30
14,145.30
BND1
10,512.24
10,512.24
BOB1
2,046.94
2,046.94
BRL1
3,876.07
3,876.07
BSD1
14,145.30
14,145.30
BTC1
105,899,478
105,899,478
BTN1
207.19
207.19
BWP1
1,427.85
1,427.85
BYN1
7,086.24
7,086.24
BZD1
7,036.94
7,036.94
CAD1
10,976.83
10,976.83
CDF1
8.76
8.76
CHF1
14,268.93
14,268.93
CLF1
617,159.97
617,159.97
CLP1
22.56
22.56
CNH1
2,218.34
2,218.34
CNY1
2,217.96
2,217.96
COP1
4.87
4.87
CRC1
25.01
25.01
CUC1
14,145.30
14,145.30
CUP1
554.71
554.71
CVE1
149.98
149.98
CZK1
642.82
642.82
DJF1
79.49
79.49
DKK1
2,225.99
2,225.99
DOP1
285.56
285.56
DZD1
121.59
121.59
EGP1
789.46
789.46
ERN1
941.13
941.13
ETB1
513.99
513.99
EUR1
16,581.27
16,581.27
FJD1
6,857.51
6,857.51
FKP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
GBP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
GEL1
5,726.61
5,726.61
GGP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
GHS1
3,041.94
3,041.94
GIP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
GMD1
299.95
299.95
GNF1
1.57
1.57
GTQ1
1,896.70
1,896.70
GYD1
67.71
67.71
HKD1
1,802.47
1,802.47
HNL1
592.76
592.76
HRK1
2,242.51
2,242.51
HTG1
219.77
219.77
HUF1
51.92
51.92
IDR1
1.00
1.00
ILS1
3,966.63
3,966.63
IMP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
INR1
207.19
207.19
IQD1
11.88
11.88
IRR1
0.33
0.33
ISK1
133.90
133.90
JEP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
JMD1
112.08
112.08
JOD1
19,936.92
19,936.92
JPY1
129.39
129.39
KES1
139.92
139.92
KGS1
207.06
207.06
KHR1
3.47
3.47
KMF1
33.69
33.69
KPW1
15.71
15.71
KRW1
13.09
13.09
KWD1
46,848.22
46,848.22
KYD1
16,973.01
16,973.01
KZT1
43.36
43.36
LAK1
1.69
1.69
LBP1
9.33
9.33
LKR1
89.47
89.47
LRD1
103.18
103.18
LSL1
1,119.33
1,119.33
LYD1
10,394.52
10,394.52
MAD1
1,493.28
1,493.28
MDL1
841.35
841.35
MGA1
4.32
4.32
MKD1
269.18
269.18
MMK1
10.44
10.44
MNT1
5.87
5.87
MOP1
1,749.93
1,749.93
MRO1
39.73
39.73
MRU1
396.11
396.11
MUR1
408.27
408.27
MVR1
912.02
912.02
MWK1
19.65
19.65
MXN1
722.40
722.40
MYR1
3,554.57
3,554.57
MZN1
234.11
234.11
NAD1
1,116.88
1,116.88
NGN1
39.31
39.31
NIO1
450.43
450.43
NOK1
1,746.35
1,746.35
NPR1
129.48
129.48
NZD1
9,801.28
9,801.28
OMR1
36,743.25
36,743.25
PAB1
14,145.30
14,145.30
PEN1
4,327.14
4,327.14
PGK1
4,332.66
4,332.66
PHP1
269.32
269.32
PKR1
122.28
122.28
PLN1
3,847.33
3,847.33
PYG1
2.48
2.48
QAR1
3,885.00
3,885.00
RON1
3,581.60
3,581.60
RSD1
140.29
140.29
RUB1
229.77
229.77
RWF1
16.32
16.32
SAR1
3,771.88
3,771.88
SBD1
1,790.84
1,790.84
SCR1
1,051.30
1,051.30
SDG1
783.50
783.50
SEK1
1,613.75
1,613.75
SGD1
10,554.57
10,554.57
SHP1
18,930.22
18,930.22
SLL1
1.80
1.80
SOS1
24.56
24.56
SRD1
1,894.12
1,894.12
SSP1
108.59
108.59
STD1
0.67
0.67
STN1
676.16
676.16
SVC1
1,616.54
1,616.54
SYP1
27.46
27.46
SZL1
1,119.88
1,119.88
THB1
441.84
441.84
TJS1
1,574.14
1,574.14
TMT1
4,030.02
4,030.02
TND1
5,576.26
5,576.26
TOP1
6,206.88
6,206.88
TRY1
2,973.29
2,973.29
TTD1
2,098.57
2,098.57
TWD1
472.64
472.64
TZS1
6.19
6.19
UAH1
541.50
541.50
UGX1
3.76
3.76
USD1
14,145.30
14,145.30
UYU1
452.88
452.88
UZS1
1.76
1.76
VEF1
0.17
0.17
VND1
0.62
0.62
VUV1
132.14
132.14
WST1
5,503.79
5,503.79
XAF1
25.27
25.27
XAG1
235,660.45
235,660.45
XAU1
18,451,763.69
18,451,763.69
XCD1
5,234.05
5,234.05
XDR1
20,072.17
20,072.17
XOF1
25.27
25.27
XPD1
13,826,603.35
13,826,603.35
XPF1
138.95
138.95
XPT1
12,891,716.09
12,891,716.09
YER1
56.50
56.50
ZAR1
1,138.22
1,138.22
ZMW1
1,377.87
1,377.87
ZWL1
43.88
43.88
Taxation Exchange Rates
31 Aug 16 - 06 Sep 16
USD 1
13,232.00
AUD 1
10,043.30
CAD 1
10,213.70
DKK 1
1,999.40
HKD 1
1,706.22
MYR 1
3,283.28
NZD 1
9,623.63
NOK 1
1,605.23
GBP 1
17,433.70
SGD 1
9,757.68
SEK 1
1,569.45
CHF 1
13,631.10
JPY 100
13,101.00
MMK 1
11.01
INR 1
197.29
KWD 1
43,920.70
PKR 1
126.23
PHP 1
285.00
SAR 1
3,528.53
LKR 1
91.12
THB 1
382.08
BND 1
9,756.53
EUR 1
14,885.50
CNY 1
1,987.61

Okusi Associates: Indonesian Business & Management Services